Charting the course of discussion
We
have reached a point in our study of the mechanics of salvation where we
need to scrutinize the core issues of the mechanics. While we attempt to take a different approach
in our pursuit, we are not abandoning what is commonly known and laying a new
foundation. This discussion is not about
coming up with yet another model of salvation; it is for the purpose of adding value
while making a modest attempt to validate findings pertaining to issues
#2, #3, #4 and #5 presented in the study entitled A Functional Model of
Salvation , namely,
2.
What are the
roles of God and man in the onetime event of man s deliverance from bondage to
sin?
3.
What are the
roles of God and man in the lifelong process of man s salvation post deliverance
from bondage to sin?
4.
Would God
unilaterally impose his grace of salvation on a person such that the person
would have no way of resisting it?
5.
Why do some
receive salvation when Jesus returns while others do not?
Before we set sail, we need
to chart the course. We need to survey
the landscape of the discussion of the mechanics of salvation and understand
where the overall discussion has been before embarking on it. We need to scrutinize the information that is
already available and leverage what is already known and avoid expending
duplicate effort. We need to discern
what is likely and attainable and what is unlikely and unattainable and pursue
what is likely and attainable and cease expending effort on what is unlikely
and unattainable. We need to assess the
defensibility of a position before engaging in its defense.
It is our obsession with our
own pet theology being correct that has hindered us from scrutinizing the big
picture and analyzing the direction that we should take; we are so concerned
about fine theological details that we have neglected it. If we would spend some time focusing on the
big picture and assessing the defensibility of our position on the mechanics of
salvation, it will save us a tremendous amount of trouble in identifying the
more likely mechanics in scriptures.
Lk 14:31 Or suppose a
king is about to go to war against another king. Will he not first sit down and
consider whether he is able with ten thousand men to oppose the one coming
against him with twenty thousand?
Lk 14:32 If he is not
able, he will send a delegation while the other is still a long way off and
will ask for terms of peace.
Jesus advised us to assess
the defensibility of a position before plunging into its defense. If it is not defensible, we need to seek
reconciliation. We should do the same
with the position we take regarding the mechanics of salvation it is
biblical.
In the context of God s enablement
and man s independent choice in man s salvation there are two types of position
extreme positions and middle positions.
An extreme position is one that cannot accommodate dissenting evidence
to any extent whatsoever without losing its credibility. A middle position is one that can accommodate
dissenting evidence to a certain extent without losing its credibility. The two extreme positions are diametrically
opposed to one another and occupy the opposite ends in the entire spectrum of
positions while there is a myriad of middle positions with different shades of
grey in the continuum between the two extreme positions.
An extreme position permits
no shade of grey, tolerates no opposing positions and excludes all other
possibilities. It uses the criterion of
correct-or-wrong as the measure for relevant positions and has an unrelenting demand
for being singularly correct. That is
what makes it extreme. It can be
validated only when all evidence points to that one position and there is
unequivocal evidence for it. When that
is not the case, an extreme position cannot be validated. When there is one single piece of evidence
that suggests otherwise, its validity is in doubt.
The myriad of middle positions
permit shades of grey, accommodate opposing positions and include other
possibilities. They employ the criterion
of possibility and likelihood as the measure of relevant positions and do not
insist on being singularly correct. That
is what makes for middle positions. They
are legitimate as long as the two extreme positions that are diametrically
opposed to one another can be shown to be relevant and have only partial
contribution to reality, implying that neither has the support of unequivocal
evidence. It is only when either one
extreme position or the other can be validated with unequivocal evidence that
middle positions can be invalidated.
The validation requirement
for extreme positions is very stringent.
It takes a tremendous amount of effort to validate an extreme position
and to prove its correctness because it needs to completely demolish every
dissenting argument, especially in contexts that are vague and suggest shades
of grey. Adopting an extreme position
requires absolute certainty of its validity.
Absolute certainty does not exist in the presence of shades of
grey. In the presence of shades of grey,
exact correctness is difficult to come by because every position, extreme or
middle, has a certain amount of truth in it.
In that situation the more reasonable measure for validity is
possibility and likelihood.
An extreme position in the pervasive
presence of shades of grey is possible but unlikely. An extreme position is therefore a very
difficult position to defend in the pervasive presence of shades of grey and we
should seriously consider relaxing the extreme position to middle positions in
that situation. On the other hand we
must not shy away from defending an extreme position if there is unequivocal
evidence for it. When an extreme
position is backed by unequivocal evidence, the other extreme position and the myriad
of middle positions are invalidated.
When we hold a middle position, we hold a
more fluid and flexible view than when we hold an extreme position because
middle positions permit shades of grey and are more open to adjustment. We would not consider our view to be absolute
truth because a middle position is only part of the continuum of a myriad of
middle positions in the presence of shades of grey. On the other hand extreme positions are rigid
and inflexible because they do not permit shades of grey and are not open to
adjustment. When we hold an extreme
position, we inevitably consider our view to be absolute truth and we have an
obsession with exact correctness.
Middle positions are
compromise between extreme positions that are diametrically opposed to one
another and that carry a fragment of truth in them. Middle positions accommodate such extreme
positions in the presence of shades of grey.
They are not opposed to extreme positions but rather opposed to the
claim of extreme positions to be the sole and whole truth when they only carry
a fragment of the truth. Middle
positions reconcile such extreme positions and bring about harmony and coherence
in common understanding. In the presence
of shades of grey extreme positions divide; middle positions unite. Extreme positions divide because they ignore
evidence contrary to the assumed extreme positions - it is a sure formula for
division. Middle positions are attempts
at accommodating all evidence - it is in a better position to unite in the
presence of shades of grey.
The position that man s salvation
is entirely of God s enablement cannot accommodate any evidence in scriptures that
suggests that man has an independent choice in coming to faith in Jesus for his
salvation, however small. The moment
such evidence exists, its credibility is in doubt. Scriptures are completely cut and dry in
regard to God s exclusive enablement in man s coming to faith according to the
position; there is no shade of grey at all with God providing the sole enablement
in man s salvation. This puts the
position under the category of extreme position. In order to validate the position one must
show that there is no dissenting evidence in scriptures at all. One must completely demolish every argument
that claims biblical backing for man s independent choice in coming to faith in
Jesus for his salvation.
In the same way the position
that man s salvation is entirely of man s choosing cannot accommodate any
evidence in scriptures that suggests that God provides enablement in man s
coming to faith in Jesus for his salvation.
The moment such evidence exists, the position is not credible. Scriptures are completely cut and dry in
regard to man s exclusive independent choice in his coming to faith according
to the position. There is no shade of
grey at all with man being the sole deciding factor in his salvation. This puts the position under the category of
extreme position. In order to validate
the position one must show that there is no dissenting evidence in scriptures at
all. One must completely demolish every
argument that claims biblical backing for God s enablement in man s coming to
faith in Jesus for his salvation.
On the other hand the
position that man s salvation is of both God and man can accommodate evidence
in scriptures that suggests that both God and man have a part to play in man s
coming to faith in Jesus for his salvation to the extent that they are not
mutually exclusive, meaning that it can accommodate any level of God s
enablement and man s independent choice as long as they do not exclude each
other. Scriptures are not cut and dry
and manifest shades of grey in regard to God s enablement and man s independent
choice in man s coming to faith according to the position. In order to validate the position one must
show that both God and man have a part to play in man s salvation. Such validation immediately counters
arguments that claim biblical backing for the exclusivity of God s enablement
in man s coming to faith and arguments that claim biblical backing for the
exclusivity of man s independent choice in his coming to faith. Please note that one does not need to
completely demolish arguments for extreme positions but simply moderate the
claim of extreme positions from exclusivity to mutuality.
By virtue of the fact that
abundant biblical evidence has been cited to suggest God s enablement in man s
salvation by many believers and man s independent choice in his salvation by
many others through the centuries to this day, the pervasive presence of shades
of grey in the context of man s salvation in scriptures has already been duly
established. In other words the middle
position that both God and man have a part to play in man s coming to faith in
Jesus for his salvation has already been validated through the collective effort
of believers over time.
The more diverse the points
of view, the greater the contention of opposing views, the more vigorous the
argument, the longer the conflict having evaded resolution, the more it
testifies to the pervasive presence of shades of grey in the context of man s
salvation in scriptures. Believers who
have taken up opposing positions through the centuries have unknowingly and
collectively cast their votes in favor of shades of grey. It is the pervasive presence of shades of
grey in various aspects of man s salvation in scriptures that has engendered a
diversity of view points and kept the contention alive through the centuries
among a multitude of believers.
It has been proven difficult
for anyone to completely demolish arguments claiming biblical backing of God s enablement
in man s salvation in the context of scriptures; it has also been proven difficult
for anyone to completely demolish arguments claiming biblical backing of man s independent
choice in his salvation in the context of scriptures. It is difficult to look those believers in
the eyes who hold middle positions on the mechanics of salvation and tell
them that there is absolutely not one single piece of evidence in all of
scriptures to support the mutuality of their middle positions and only evidence
to support the exclusivity of an extreme position. When we make claims such as salvation being entirely of
God s enablement alone or salvation being entirely of man s choosing alone, we
would have to go through every verse of scriptures and account for every
indication otherwise in order to maintain those claims. That is the only way to defend such extreme
positions. Extreme positions on the mechanics of salvation are therefore very
difficult to defend in light of the pervasive presence of shades of grey in the
context of salvation in scriptures. It is an insurmountable task for either one of the two
extreme positions.
We need to strive for a doctrinal
position on salvation that has broad biblical backing for the welfare of
believers; a doctrinal position on salvation with broad biblical backing is
what is needed for the welfare of believers.
Doctrines are intended for mass consumption and must be safe for that
purpose. Doctrines must be based on a
multiplicity of evidence in scriptures for it to be biblically safe and
sound. We must refrain from promoting a
doctrine of salvation that does not have broad biblical backing and the support
of a multiplicity of evidence in scriptures.
When we do, we promote our own ideology at the expense of the welfare of
believers.
It is inappropriate to base the doctrine of salvation on a
single potentially fallible and vague idea that manifests shades of grey in
scriptures. The extreme position that
man s coming to faith in Jesus for his salvation is entirely of God s
enablement alone is based on the assumption that man is totally unable to
respond to the things of God. The other
extreme position that man s coming to faith in Jesus for his salvation is
entirely of man s choosing alone is based on the assumption that man is fully
capable of summoning up faith from within himself. These assumptions do not have the support of
unequivocal evidence in scriptures and are weakened by pervasive presence of
shades of grey. It is inappropriate to
base the doctrine of salvation singularly on any of such assumptions because
the moment such an assumption is in doubt, the corresponding extreme position
is in doubt.
The lack of graceful degradation and hence resiliency testifies to the
inherent weakness of extreme positions on salvation. If a man has a sizeable fortune and one day
he forgets to lock the front gate to his house and he ends up losing his entire
fortune, the man is rather negligent in safeguarding his fortune by way of
distributing it in various safe places. An
extreme position on salvation can be likened to that. It is again akin to a skyscraper that when a
truck slams into it knocking down one of its pillars, the entire skyscraper comes tumbling down to its ruin. It shows that the skyscraper is architecturally
unsound by design.
Rather the doctrine of
salvation must have broad biblical backing and the support of a multiplicity of
evidence in scriptures it must be biblically safe and sound. Middle positions on the mechanics of salvation have broad biblical backing and the support
of a multiplicity of evidence because there is a pervasive presence of shades
of grey in various aspects in the context of salvation in scriptures. In the pervasive presence of shades of grey
any middle position deviates from the reality of salvation in scriptures in
details while extreme positions in principle.
When an extreme position cannot completely eliminate shades of grey, it
needs to moderate.
Those who hold an extreme
position on the doctrine of salvation do not need to abandon their position;
they only need to moderate and relax the assumption that they alone have the
stranglehold on the truth of scriptures in regard to salvation. Please note that historically many believers
have already moderated from the two extreme positions on man s salvation - it
is moderation from exclusivity to mutuality.
Those who hold middle positions need to collaborate with others to
adjust to a more likely middle position in the continuum. If we are willing to put aside our pet theology
for a moment and give some thought to other positions on salvation along this
line, we would be more effective and efficient in arriving at the proper doctrine
of salvation with broad biblical backing.
Contention over the doctrine
of salvation has gone on for too long and caused enough division. A household that is rife with strife and
contention is harmful to the development of a child. In the same way division and contention within
the household of God is harmful to the spiritual development of believers. In addition it incurs an opportunity cost in
terms of siphoning off resources that could have been expended in doing the
work of the gospel instead. Division and
contention over the doctrine of salvation in the present context is becoming
increasingly unjustifiable with the passage of time for the adverse impact it
has on the household of God. It is time
for proper arbitration and resolution. It
is imperative that we leverage the collective wisdom of believers through the
centuries and accept the reality and the authority of the collective vote they
have cast in favor of shades of grey in the context of salvation in scriptures.
We need to consider what
believers have passed on through the centuries a legacy to inherit and not division
and contention to perpetuate. Accepting
the reality and the authority of their collective vote is how we can receive
what they have passed down as a legacy.
It is through such a change in our thinking that we can pass on coherent
common understanding instead of division and contention. What future generations will inherit from us
depends entirely on our attitude. We
need to think more for future generations.
We can be the generation of believers who can collaborate with one
another and work out our differences on the mechanics of salvation. We can be the generation of believers who put
an end to the perpetual division and contention. We can choose to be a blessing and a positive
example for those who come after us. We
have a choice to make. And the choice we
make will be an impactful one for the household of God, for better or for
worse, whether it is seeking resolution or perpetuating the status quo.
Now that we have charted the
course of discussion, we are going to validate findings pertaining to issues #2, #3, #4 and #5 presented in the study
entitled A Functional Model of Salvation .
The validation will add to our understanding of the presence of shades
of grey in the context of salvation in scriptures. It is understandable that the validation very
likely contains errors. But that does
not take away from the fact that the appropriate doctrine of salvation should
be based on middle positions and not extreme positions because believers
through the centuries have cast their collective vote in favor of shades of
grey.
Please
note that the logic that is extensively used throughout the validation is
rather simple and not sophisticated at all.
In fact it is part of the high school curriculum in school systems in
parts of the world. No advanced skills
or knowledge are required for understanding the validation.
Issue #2: What are the roles of God
and man in the onetime event of man s deliverance from bondage to sin?
In regard to issue #2 we are
going to validate the following from scriptures:
Repentance causatively
precedes salvation.
Repentance
causatively precedes deliverance from bondage to sin.
Repentance is man s responsibility.
Repentance brings about willingness to obey.
Regeneration, the granting of the gift of faith and deliverance
from bondage to sin by the Holy Spirit are chronologically synchronous, with
regeneration causative-immediately preceding the granting of the gift of faith,
which in turn causative-immediately precedes deliverance.
Belief in the context of scriptures can
refer to mere mental assent, more than mental assent but not necessarily faith,
or faith.
Belief as in
mental assent to
the good news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by repentance causatively
precedes regeneration,
the granting of the gift of faith and deliverance from bondage to sin by the
Holy Spirit with regeneration, the granting of the gift of faith and
deliverance being chronologically synchronous and regeneration
causative-immediately preceding the granting of the gift of faith, which in
turn causative-immediately precedes deliverance.
Unbelief
leads to the blinding of the mind of an unbeliever by the god of this age and
the non-granting of the gift of faith by God.
Though
he is willing, a repentant person is not able to escape the destruction of sin
on his own; God has to deliver him, which is a sovereign act of God.
God
provisions for the elect the root cause, the preceding and independent part of
the intermediate cause and the immediate cause while man the subsequent and
dependent part of the intermediate cause on the only causal chain of deliverance
from bondage to sin.
Repentance causatively
precedes salvation
2Co 7:10
Godly sorrow brings repentance that leads to salvation
and leaves no regret, but worldly sorrow brings death.
This verse of scriptures shows
that repentance is a sufficient condition for salvation. But this statement on the verse does not
adequately capture the meaning of the verse in that it does not indicate that
repentance is a cause and salvation an effect.
In fact the designation of a sufficient condition only indicates the
implied relationship but not the causal relationship. A more adequate way of putting it would be to
say that repentance is a sufficient condition that is causal for salvation.
Lk 13:1 Now there were some present at that time who told Jesus
about the Galileans whose blood Pilate had mixed with their sacrifices.
Lk 13:2 Jesus answered,
Do you think that these Galileans were worse sinners than all the other
Galileans because they suffered this way?
Lk 13:3 I tell you, no!
But unless you repent, you too will all perish.
Lk 13:4 Or those
eighteen who died when the tower in Siloam fell on them do you think they were
more guilty than all the others living in Jerusalem?
Lk 13:5 I tell you, no!
But unless you repent, you too will all perish.
Jesus warning shows that
repentance is a necessary condition that is causal for salvation. Taken together, the above passages of scriptures provide
evidence that repentance is a sufficient and necessary condition that is causal
for salvation.
When repentance
is said to be a sufficient condition that is causal for salvation, it is
unknown whether it is an immediate cause or a more intermediate cause of
salvation. That being the case, we
should assume that there is a causal chain that leads to salvation and
repentance is a cause on that causal chain.
Please note that a causal chain that leads to an end effect can have
multiple causes in the chain with one leading to another that ultimately leads
to the end effect. Furthermore it is
also unknown whether there are other causal chains that lead to salvation and that
do not carry repentance as a cause. That
being the case, we should assume that repentance is on one of the causal chains
of salvation. But since repentance is
also a necessary condition that is causal for salvation, we can conclude that
there is only one causal chain of salvation and repentance is a cause on that
causal chain, or that there are multiple causal chains of salvation and
repentance is on each one of them. In
the latter case the multiple causal chains of salvation always lead to
repentance that ultimately leads to salvation.
We will assume the former case to be true unless there is indication in
scriptures for the latter, i.e., there is only one causal chain of salvation
and repentance is a cause on that causal chain.
Alternatively we
can say that repentance causatively precedes salvation on the only causal chain
of salvation. But for simplicity sake we
are going to say that repentance causatively precedes salvation. It is assumed in the current sub-study that
causatively preceding means being a cause on the only causal chain of . This will facilitate later discussion as we
shall see.
Repentance causatively
precedes deliverance from bondage to sin
Please note that repentance causatively
preceding salvation also causatively precedes the onetime event of deliverance
from bondage to sin because deliverance from bondage to sin inaugurates the
process of salvation.
Repentance
is man s responsibility
Mt 11:20 Then
Jesus began to denounce the cities in which most of his miracles had been
performed, because they did not repent.
Mt 11:21 Woe to you, Korazin! Woe to you, Bethsaida! If the miracles
that were performed in you had been performed in Tyre
and Sidon, they would have repented long ago in sackcloth and ashes.
Mt 11:22 But I tell you,
it will be more bearable for Tyre and Sidon on the day of judgment than for you.
Mt 11:23 And you, Capernaum, will you be lifted up to the skies? No,
you will go down to the depths. If the miracles that were performed in you had
been performed in Sodom, it would have remained to this day.
Mt 11:24 But I tell you
that it will be more bearable for Sodom on the day of
judgment than for you.
Apparently it was not
miracles or God s enablement alone that caused people to repent. Otherwise people in Korazin,
Bethsaida and Capernaum would have repented when they saw the miracles
performed by Jesus. Had the same
miracles been performed in Tyre, Sidon and Sodom,
people there would have repented according to Jesus. The difference can only be accounted for by
the difference in inclination for repentance on the part of man and not God s
enablement because the same miracles applied.
In other words people in Tyre, Sidon and Sodom
were more inclined to repent than people in Korazin,
Bethsaida and Capernaum under the same circumstance.
Lk 11:29 As the crowds increased, Jesus said, This is a wicked
generation. It asks for a miraculous sign, but none will be given it except the
sign of Jonah.
Lk 11:30 For as Jonah was
a sign to the Ninevites, so also will the Son of Man
be to this generation.
Lk 11:31 The Queen of the
South will rise at the judgment with the men of this generation and condemn
them; for she came from the ends of the earth to listen to Solomon s wisdom,
and now one greater than Solomon is here.
Lk 11:32 The men of Nineveh will stand up at the judgment with this
generation and condemn it; for they repented at the preaching of Jonah, and now
one greater than Jonah is here.
People made repentance a
matter of God s enablement in asking for a miraculous sign but Jesus refuted
their argument and used the men of Nineveh and the Queen of the South to poke
through their hypocrisy. In a way they
were blaming their lack of repentance on God and Jesus pushed the
responsibility for repentance back on them.
People who ask for a miracle before they would repent or believe have
neither a repentant spirit, nor a heart that is receptive to the truth, nor a
heart that loves the truth. The
generation referred to by Jesus would not repent even though Jesus who was
greater than Jonah and Solomon was with that generation, while the men of
Nineveh did at the preaching of Jonah and the Queen of the South came from the ends
of the earth to listen to Solomon s wisdom.
In other words that generation refused to repent even with a more
compelling reason while these others repented with a less compelling one. It again shows that some are more inclined to
repent than others and that man has responsibility for his repentance.
For that reason the
generation referred to by Jesus deserve condemnation by the Ninevites
and the Queen of the South. If
repentance is entirely of God alone, there is no ground for the Nivevites and the Queen of the South to condemn that
generation. But because they had a
personal responsibility for repentance and they did not repent even with a more
compelling reason, that generation deserves condemnation by those who did with
a less compelling one - the latter will be God s witnesses against the former
for their refusal to repent. And these
witnesses will be from different eras of Jewish history.
Lk 16:27 He (the rich
man) answered, Then I beg you, father, send Lazarus to my father s house,
Lk 16:28 for I have five
brothers. Let him warn them, so that they will not also come to this place of
torment.
Lk 16:29 Abraham
replied, They have Moses and the Prophets; let them
listen to them.
Lk 16:30 No, father Abraham, he said, but if someone from the
dead goes to them, they will repent.
Lk 16:31 He said to him,
If they do not listen to Moses and the Prophets, they will not be convinced
even if someone rises from the dead.
The rich man was laying the
responsibility for man s repentance on God in claiming that his five brothers
would repent if Abraham would send Lazarus to warn them as one who rose from
the dead. In a subtle way he was blaming
God for his own non-repentance because God had not enabled him while he was
still living. But Abraham pushed back
and laid the responsibility on man for his own repentance. He made it clear that the rich man s brothers
could repent by listening to Moses and the Prophets alone and hence did not
need God s special enablement for repentance.
Let them listen to them in verse 29 indicates that it was entirely the
responsibility of the rich man s brothers to listen to Moses and the Prophets. The idea is that if a person does not have a heart that is receptive to the truth and a heart that
loves the truth, he would not repent even when someone rises from the dead to
warn him as special enablement from God for him to repent.
Holding to the view that man s repentance
is solely God s responsibility can be detrimental - the rich man is an example. No one should be waiting for God s special enablement
before he repents - there are instructions in scriptures for him to do so. He can repent any time if he so chooses
because it is his personal responsibility to heed the warning for repentance in
scriptures. Instead of obeying
instructions in scriptures for repentance as man s responsibility, the rich man
was looking for extra-biblical enablement for repentance as God s
responsibility. He did not know how he
had failed to repent even while he was suffering the consequence of non-repentance. Was it due to ignorance? No. He
could have listened to Moses and the Prophets while he was still alive. But he did not and that was why he was
suffering the consequence. We will
suffer the same consequence if we refuse to heed warnings in scriptures for us
to repent.
2Pe 3:8 But do not forget this one thing, dear friends: With the
Lord a day is like a thousand years, and a thousand years are like a day.
2Pe 3:9 The Lord is not
slow in keeping his promise, as some understand slowness. He is patient with
you, not wanting anyone to perish, but everyone to come to repentance.
If repentance is entirely of God alone,
God is not being patient with us; he is being patient with himself. It is when we can choose to repent that God
is being patient with us. If he provides
the sole enablement for repentance, his patience would have been completely in
vain; he could wait for the entire eternity and nobody would ever repent. This shows that man s repentance is not of God
alone; man has a part in it. Please note that man is unable to fulfill the
responsibility of repentance on his own; he needs to be assisted in fulfilling
it.
Jn 12:30 Jesus said,
This voice was for your benefit, not mine.
Jn 12:31 Now is the time
for judgment on this world; now the prince of this world will be driven
out.
Jn 12:32 But I, when I am
lifted up from the earth, will draw all men to myself.
Jn
12:33 He said this to show the kind of death he was going to
die.
Please note that it is not a simple
matter of man taking the initiative to repent and to be willing to obey the
good news of Jesus Christ on his own; rather Jesus has to draw man to himself
first. And Jesus has been drawing all
men to himself ever since he died on the cross.
Everyone can repent
upon Jesus drawing but not everyone is willing to repent.
Jn 16:8 When he (the
Holy Spirit) comes, he will convict the world of guilt in regard to sin and
righteousness and judgment.
Again it is not a simple matter of man taking the initiative to repent
on his own; rather the Holy Spirit has to convict man of guilt in regard to sin
and righteousness and judgment first.
And the Holy Spirit has been convicting the world of guilt ever since he
came into the world. Everyone can repent under the convicting
work of the Holy Spirit but not everyone is willing to repent.
Repentance
brings about willingness to obey
Repentance
is the willingness to turn from disobedience to obedience to God. When a person repents, he becomes willing to
obey God.
Mt 21:28 What do you
think? There was a man who had two sons. He went to the first and said, Son,
go and work today in the vineyard.
Mt 21:29 I will not, he answered, but later he changed his mind
and went.
Mt 21:30 Then the father
went to the other son and said the same thing. He answered, I
will, sir, but he did not go.
Mt 21:31 Which of the
two did what his father wanted? The first, they answered. Jesus said to
them, I tell you the truth, the tax collectors and the prostitutes are entering
the
Mt 21:32 For John came to
you to show you the way of righteousness, and you did not believe him, but the
tax collectors and the prostitutes did. And even after you saw this, you did
not repent and believe him.
Jesus was using an example of the
relationship between a father and his two sons to illustrate repentance. Repentance is a change of mind from
disobedience to obedience as seen in the first son - the spirit of repentance is the spirit of obedience. It engenders willingness to obey.
Lk 3:3 He (John the
Baptist) went into all the country around the Jordan, preaching a baptism of
repentance for the forgiveness of sins.
John s baptism was a baptism of
repentance.
Lk 3:7 John said to the
crowds coming out to be baptized by him, You brood of vipers! Who warned you
to flee from the coming wrath?
Lk 3:8 Produce fruit in
keeping with repentance. And do not begin to say to yourselves,
We have Abraham as our father. For I tell you that out of these stones God can
raise up children for Abraham.
Lk 3:9 The ax is already at the root of the trees, and every tree
that does not produce good fruit will be cut down and thrown into the fire.
Lk 3:10 What should we
do then? the crowd asked.
Lk 3:11 John answered,
The man with two tunics should share with him who has none, and the one who
has food should do the same.
Lk 3:12 Tax collectors
also came to be baptized. Teacher, they asked, what should we do?
Lk 3:13 Don t collect
any more than you are required to, he told them.
Lk 3:14 Then some
soldiers asked him, And what should we do? He replied, Don t extort money
and don t accuse people falsely be content
with your pay.
People repented when they
came out to be baptized by John because John s baptism is the baptism of
repentance. Invariably they asked what
they should do; they were willing to obey the instruction they would be given -
the spirit of repentance is the spirit of obedience. Again repentance engenders willingness to
obey. Please note that John s
instruction for the crowd is part of scriptures. Therefore the willingness to obey is the
willingness to obey instructions in scriptures.
Ac 2:36
Therefore let all Israel be assured of this: God has made this Jesus, whom you
crucified, both Lord and Christ.
Ac 2:37 When
the people heard this, they were cut to the heart and said to Peter and the
other apostles, Brothers, what shall we do?
Ac 2:38
Peter replied, Repent and be baptized, every
one of you, in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins. And
you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.
People were cut to the heart
and repented when they heard Peter s message.
They asked what they should do.
They were willing to obey whatever instruction they would be given - the spirit of repentance is the spirit of obedience. Again repentance engenders willingness to
obey. The willingness to obey is
the willingness to obey instructions in scriptures because Peter s instruction
for the people is part of scriptures.
Ac 16:25 About midnight Paul and Silas were praying and singing hymns
to God, and the other prisoners were listening to them.
Ac 16:26 Suddenly there was such a violent earthquake that the
foundations of the prison were shaken. At once all the prison doors flew open,
and everybody s chains came loose.
Ac 16:27 The jailer woke up, and when he saw the prison doors open,
he drew his sword and was about to kill himself because he thought the
prisoners had escaped.
Ac 16:28 But
Paul shouted, Don t harm yourself! We are all here!
Ac 16:29 The jailer called for lights, rushed in and fell trembling
before Paul and Silas.
Ac 16:30 He then brought
them out and asked, Sirs, what must I do to be saved?
Ac 16:31 They replied, Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be
saved you and your household.
Ac 16:32 Then
they spoke the word of the Lord to him and to all the others in his house.
Ac 16:33 At that hour of the night the jailer took them and washed
their wounds; then immediately he and all his family were baptized.
Ac 16:34 The
jailer brought them into his house and set a meal before them; he was filled
with joy because he had come to believe in God he and his whole family.
Please note that
the violent earthquake and the prison doors flying
open and everybody s chain coming loose were God s special enablement for the
jailer to repent. But he did not repent
at first because his immediate reaction was to kill himself. It was when Paul and Silas spared his life by
not fleeing that the miracle became an effective enablement for repentance,
whereupon he did not want to kill himself any more but instead asked what he
must do to be saved. He repented when he
no longer wanted to kill himself and was willing to obey whatever instruction
he would be given - the spirit
of repentance is the spirit of obedience.
Again repentance engenders willingness to obey. The willingness to obey is the willingness to
obey instructions in scriptures because the instruction from Paul and Silas for
the jailer is part of scriptures.
Regeneration,
the granting of the gift of faith and deliverance from bondage to sin by the
Holy Spirit are chronologically synchronous, with regeneration causative-immediately
preceding the granting of the gift of faith, which in turn causative-immediately
precedes deliverance
We are going to identify from scriptures the chronological and causal
relationship of regeneration by the Holy Spirit, faith and deliverance from
bondage to sin. In addition we are going
to identify the party that provisions faith and deliverance.
Tit 3:4 But
when the kindness and love of God our Savior appeared,
Tit 3:5 he
saved us, not because of righteous things we had done, but because of his
mercy. He saved us through the washing of rebirth and renewal by the Holy
Spirit,
Tit 3:6 whom
he poured out on us generously through Jesus Christ our Savior,
Tit 3:7 so that, having been
justified by his grace, we might become heirs having the hope of eternal life.
The salvation
mentioned in verse 5 refers to the onetime event of deliverance from bondage to
sin through regeneration by the Holy Spirit.
Please note the past tense of the act of salvation that signifies that it
refers to the onetime event that has taken place in the life of a believer. In other words regeneration by the Holy
Spirit is a sufficient condition that is causal for deliverance from bondage to
sin.
Jn 3:3 In reply Jesus declared, I tell you the truth, no one can
see the kingdom of God unless he is born again.
Jn 3:4 How can a man be born when he is old? Nicodemus asked. Surely he cannot
enter a second time into his mother s womb to be born!
Jn 3:5 Jesus answered,
I tell you the truth, no one can enter the kingdom of God unless he is born of
water and the Spirit.
In this passage of scriptures
Jesus declared that regeneration by the Holy Spirit is a necessary condition that
is causal for a person s seeing and entering the kingdom of God. Seeing and entering the kingdom of God can
refer to the end effect of the onetime event of deliverance from bondage to sin
or to the end effect of the lifelong process of salvation. Since the onetime event of deliverance from
bondage to sin inaugurates the lifelong process of salvation, regeneration must
be a necessary condition that is causal for deliverance, whether seeing and
entering the kingdom of God refers to the end effect of the onetime event of
deliverance or to the end effect of the lifelong process of salvation.
From the above two passages
of scriptures we have come to the following understanding about regeneration by
the Holy Spirit:
Regeneration by
the Holy Spirit is a sufficient condition that is causal for deliverance from
bondage to sin.
Regeneration by the
Holy Spirit is a necessary condition that is causal for deliverance from
bondage to sin.
Regeneration by the Holy
Spirit is therefore a sufficient and necessary condition that is causal for
deliverance. In other words regeneration
is a cause on the only causal chain of deliverance. In accordance with the convention in this
sub-study we say that regeneration by the Holy Spirit causatively precedes
deliverance from bondage to sin. Because
regeneration causatively precedes deliverance, one of the following
chronological and causal relationships between regeneration and deliverance is
true:
Regeneration by
the Holy Spirit and deliverance from bondage to sin are chronologically
synchronous with regeneration causatively preceding deliverance.
Regeneration by
the Holy Spirit chronologically and causatively precedes deliverance from
bondage to sin.
Please note that we have yet
to identify the party that renders the deliverance. We shall do that in due time as we continue.
Lk 7:50 Jesus said to
the woman, Your faith has saved you; go in peace.
Faith is an immediate cause
of salvation according to this verse of scriptures. Please note that salvation in this context
refers to deliverance from bondage to sin because it is a onetime event in the
past. In other words faith is an
immediate cause of deliverance from bondage to sin.
Ephesians 2:8-9 (Young's
Literal Translation)
8For by grace ye are having
been saved, through faith, and this not of you -- of God the gift,
9not of works, that no one
may boast.
These two verses of
scriptures constitute a declaration of the absolute and exclusive position that
faith is not conceived by man because it is the gift of God granted to man unto
salvation. Please note that salvation in
this context seems to refer to both deliverance from bondage to sin and the
process of salvation by virtue of the tense of the verb for salvation. These two verses therefore also constitute a
declaration of the absolute and exclusive position that man is delivered from
bondage to sin by faith alone and not by works.
In other words the granting of the gift of faith by God is a cause on
the only causal chain of deliverance from bondage to sin. In accordance with the convention in this
sub-study we say that the granting of the gift of faith causatively precedes
deliverance. Since faith is also an
immediate cause of deliverance as shown above, the granting of the gift of
faith therefore causative-immediately precedes deliverance from bondage to sin.
Please note that there is no
lag time in a person s deliverance from bondage to sin upon being granted the
gift of faith. This is because faith is
the immediate cause of deliverance and there is no scriptural evidence to
suggest that there is a lag time between the two. The moment a person has been granted the gift
of faith, he is delivered. The granting
of the gift of faith and deliverance both take place at the same moment with
deliverance as the immediate effect. In
other words the granting of the gift of faith and deliverance from bondage to
sin are chronologically synchronous with the granting of the gift of faith
causative-immediately preceding deliverance.
Please note that we have yet to identify the party that renders the
deliverance. We shall do so in due time
as we continue.
At this time we have
established the following:
Faith is not
conceived by man because it is the gift of God granted to man unto salvation.
Regeneration by
the Holy Spirit either chronologically precedes or is chronologically
synchronous with deliverance from bondage to sin with regeneration causatively
preceding deliverance. The party that
renders the deliverance has yet to be identified.
The granting of
the gift of faith by God and deliverance from bondage to sin are
chronologically synchronous with the granting of the gift causative-immediately
preceding deliverance. Again the party that
renders the deliverance has yet to be identified.
The above findings have shed
light on the following:
The chronological
and causal relationship between regeneration by the Holy Spirit and deliverance
from bondage to sin.
The chronological
and causal relationship between the granting of the gift of faith by God and
deliverance from bondage to sin.
What is missing is the
chronological and causal relationship between regeneration by the Holy Spirit
and the granting of the gift of faith by God.
If we can identify the missing relationship in scriptures, we can
identify the chronological and causal relationship of regeneration by the Holy
Spirit, the granting of the gift of faith by God and deliverance from bondage
to sin.
Though we have already established
that faith is not conceived by man because it is the gift of God granted to man
unto salvation, we are going to expend more effort in examining evidence in
scriptures in order to confirm our understanding in tandem with the effort of
identifying the missing chronological and causal relationship between
regeneration by the Holy Spirit and the granting of the gift of faith by God,
because both are closely related.
Heb 12:2 Let us fix our
eyes on Jesus, the author and perfecter of our faith,
who for the joy set before him endured the cross, scorning its shame, and sat
down at the right hand of the throne of God.
Jesus is the
author of faith according to this verse of scriptures. Faith is again shown not to be conceived by man. It cannot be conceived by man and must be granted
to man as a gift from God because Jesus is the sole author of faith.
2 Peter 1:1-2 (King James
Version)
1 Simon Peter, a servant and an apostle of
Jesus Christ, to them that have obtained like precious faith with us through
the righteousness of God and our Saviour Jesus
Christ:
2 Grace and peace be
multiplied unto you through the knowledge of God, and of Jesus our Lord.
The Strong's Concordance
Number for the Greek word that is translated into the word obtained in verse
1 is G2975. It is used in the New
Testaments on three other occasions. It
means casting lot to determine or receiving something by divine
appointment. It is therefore obvious
that the audience of Peter s second epistle had not conceived their faith but
had received it as a gift from God.
1 Timothy 1:14 (King James
Version)
14 And the grace of our Lord was exceeding
abundant with faith and love which is in Christ Jesus.
It is obvious that the grace
of our Lord comes from the Lord and that the love that is in Christ Jesus has
its origin in Christ Jesus. Please note
that it does not say the love that is for Christ Jesus, which might have its
origin in man. It therefore becomes
obvious that the faith in this verse does not mean the faith that man puts in
Christ Jesus but rather the faith that has its origin in Christ Jesus in
accordance with the context. In fact the
grace of our Lord and the faith and love that are in
Christ Jesus in this verse all have their origin in God.
Heb 11:1 Now
faith is being sure of what we hope for and certain of what we do not see.
This verse of
scriptures states that faith is the confidence and certainty about what we hope
for and what we do not see. Man cannot
conceive faith and can have no way of summoning up that which is from within to
hope for and to be certain of matters in the spiritual realm that he cannot
see. What is of the flesh cannot
conceive what is spiritual.
Jn 3:6 Flesh gives
birth to flesh, but the Spirit gives birth to spirit.
Man might be able to
acknowledge that God exists and come to a certain understanding of God s nature
from his observation of God s creation as Romans 1:20 points out, but would
have no way of summoning up the conviction from within to be sure and certain
of what he cannot see in the spiritual realm.
The same is true of his mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ. Mental assent in itself does not engender
conviction about the good news. Only faith that is the gift of God granted to man of the
supernatural proportion can impart such confidence and certainty about
spiritual reality.
Salvation is the
work of God of the supernatural proportion with faith as the immediate cause. It cannot have as its immediate cause
something that has an earthly origin because what is of the flesh cannot
deliver man from bondage to sin and the ultimate
destruction of sin.
Only faith that belongs in the spiritual realm and that is the gift of
God of the supernatural proportion can be the immediate cause. Furthermore God is the gatekeeper of
salvation. He alone provisions the root
cause and the immediate cause of salvation; man can have no part in either.
1 Corinthians 12:3 (King
James Version)
3 Wherefore I give you to understand, that no
man speaking by the Spirit of God calleth Jesus
accursed: and that no man can say that Jesus is the Lord, but by the Holy
Ghost.
This verse of scriptures
is a declaration of the absolute and exclusive position that the Holy Spirit is
the sole source of faith in Jesus. Because
Jesus is the sole author of faith that cannot be conceived by man, man can have
faith only when it is granted him by the Holy Spirit. Please note that it does not say that no one
can make a confession of the lordship of Jesus except by the faith that is
granted him by the Holy Spirit, but that no one can make a confession except by
the Holy Spirit. There is a sense that
no one can make such a confession apart from one s possession of the Holy
Spirit.
When we say that
by something we do such and such, we must have that something in our possession
and that something is the immediate cause for doing such and such. Please note that the Greek word that is
translated into the word by as in by the Holy Spirit has the Strong s
Concordance number G1722.
Matthew 21:23 (King James
Version)
23 And when he was come into the temple, the
chief priests and the elders of the people came unto him as he was teaching,
and said, By what authority doest thou these things? and
who gave thee this authority?
The chief priests and the
elders of the people questioned Jesus by what authority he was doing what he
was doing and who gave him the authority to do it. They acknowledged the following in their
questioning:
Jesus possession
of the authority;
The authority being
the immediate cause for Jesus doing what he was doing.
Please note that
the Greek word that is translated into by as in by what authority in the
above verse of scriptures also has the Strong Concordance number G1722. This ensures that by the Holy Spirit and
by what authority are analogous insofar as the word by is used in these two
contexts. To give a real-life example, a
university president declares at commencement:
By the authority
that is vested in me by the Board of Trustees I confer upon you the degree of
A college student
having completed his degree requirements leads to the university president
exercising his authority as the immediate cause for conferring the degree. Please note that he would not say that by the
Board of Trustees he confers the degree because he does not have the Board in
his possession.
Consequently when scriptures
say that no one can say that Jesus is Lord except by the Holy Spirit, it is
implied that no one can do so without the Holy Spirit in his possession. The following passage of scriptures lends
support to the necessity of having the Holy Spirit in our possession before we
can accept the gift of faith that is given through the Holy Spirit.
1Co 2:12 We have not received the spirit of the world but the Spirit
who is from God, that we may understand what God has freely given us.
1Co 2:13 This is what we
speak, not in words taught us by human wisdom but in words taught by the
Spirit, expressing spiritual truths in spiritual words.
1Co 2:14 The man without
the Spirit does not accept the things that come from the Spirit of God, for
they are foolishness to him, and he cannot understand them, because they are
spiritually discerned.
Verse 12 says that we have
received the Holy Spirit so that we may understand what God has given us. Therefore we have received the Holy Spirit so
that we may understand the gift of faith that God has given us. Not only that, verse 14 says that the man
without the Spirit does not accept the things that come from the Spirit of God. This includes the gift of faith given
exclusively through the Holy Spirit. In
other words we cannot receive the gift of faith from the Holy Spirit without
having been regenerated by the Holy Spirit and therefore without the Holy
Spirit in our possession. It is of
necessity that we have been regenerated by the Holy Spirit and have the Holy
Spirit in our possession before we can receive the gift of faith from the Holy
Spirit.
Ro 3:28 For we maintain
that a man is justified by faith apart from observing the law.
Man is justified exclusively
by faith according to this verse of scriptures.
1Co 6:11 And that is
what some of you were. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were
justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God.
Because we are justified by
faith and are granted the gift of faith through our possession of the Holy
Spirit, this verse of scriptures says that we are justified by the Spirit of
God. If we claim that man can conceive
faith albeit with assistance from the Holy Spirit prior to regeneration or with
enablement from the Holy Spirit post regeneration, then man is partly justified
by himself for the faith he conceives, which cannot be.
Consequently we
can establish from scriptures that possession of the Holy Spirit and hence
regeneration by the Holy Spirit is the immediate cause on the only causal chain
of the granting of the gift of faith by the Holy Spirit. In
accordance with the convention in this sub-study we say
that regeneration by the Holy Spirit causative-immediately precedes the
granting of the gift of faith by the Holy Spirit. Please note that there is no lag time in a
person s being granted the gift of faith upon being regenerated. This is because regeneration is the immediate
cause of the granting of the gift and there is no scriptural evidence to
suggest that there is a lag time between the two. It is natural for regeneration and the
granting of the gift of faith to be chronologically synchronous such that the
moment a person is regenerated, he is immediately granted the gift of
faith. In other words regeneration by
the Holy Spirit and the granting of the gift of faith by the Holy Spirit are
chronologically synchronous with regeneration causative-immediately preceding
the granting of the gift.
By this time we have
established the following chronological and causal relationships from
scriptures:
1.
Regeneration
and the granting of the gift of faith by
the Holy Spirit are chronologically synchronous with regeneration
causative-immediately preceding the granting of the gift of faith.
2.
The granting of
the gift of faith by the Holy Spirit and deliverance from bondage to sin are
chronologically synchronous with the granting of the gift of faith causative-immediately
preceding deliverance. The party that
renders the deliverance has yet to be identified.
3.
Regeneration by
the Holy Spirit either chronologically precedes or is chronologically
synchronous with deliverance from bondage to sin with regeneration causatively
preceding deliverance. The party that
renders the deliverance has yet to be identified.
By this time #3 can be
eliminated because #1 and #2 together provide a more accurate chronological and
causal relationship between regeneration by the Holy Spirit and deliverance
from bondage to sin. What has been established
can be more succinctly summarized as follows:
Regeneration
and the granting of the gift of faith by the Holy Spirit and deliverance
from bondage to sin are chronologically synchronous with regeneration
causative-immediately preceding the granting of the gift of faith, which in turn
causative-immediately precedes deliverance.
But we have yet to identify
the party that renders deliverance from bondage to sin. Please note that deliverance from bondage to
sin is the end effect of the causal chain of deliverance from bondage to sin. Since the granting of the gift of faith by
the Holy Spirit constitutes the immediate cause of deliverance, the Holy Spirit
who provisions the immediate cause through granting the gift is the party that
renders deliverance as the end effect of the causal chain. In other words deliverance from bondage to
sin is by the Holy Spirit just as regeneration and the granting of the gift of
faith are. This leads us to conclude from scriptures the following:
Regeneration, the granting of the gift of faith and deliverance from
bondage to sin by the Holy Spirit are chronologically synchronous, with
regeneration causative-immediately preceding the granting of the gift of faith,
which in turn causative-immediately precedes deliverance.
A person cannot
be a carrier of faith by his own conception of faith prior to regeneration, nor
by being granted the gift of faith prior to regeneration, nor by his own
conception of faith post regeneration, nor by being granted the gift of faith
post regeneration. A person is immediately
a carrier of faith at the very moment he is regenerated by the Holy Spirit who
is the sole source of faith that is granted to man. Apart from regeneration, he cannot be a
carrier; he is immediately a carrier by virtue of the regeneration and not through
his conceiving faith or through a separate process of being granted the gift of
faith post regeneration. He who is regenerated by the Holy Spirit has faith; he
who is not regenerated by the Holy Spirit does not have faith. The moment the Holy Spirit regenerates a person, the person is delivered
from bondage to sin through the faith that is in his possession by virtue of
the regeneration.
Belief in the context of scriptures
can refer to mere mental assent, more than mental assent but not necessarily faith,
or faith
Jas 2:19 You believe that there is one God. Good! Even the demons
believe that and shudder.
Do the demons believe that there is one
God? Certainly and more than anyone of
us does. Demons believe but are not
willing to obey God. And faith is
irrelevant for them because they see God face to face. Therefore belief in scriptures does not
necessarily refer to faith. One can
believe without having faith or the need for faith. Therefore belief and faith are two different
things in scriptures and not one and the same.
In the context of the above verse
of scriptures demons do nothing more than provisioning mental assent. Mental assent is the acknowledgment of something to be
true but does not necessarily engender obedience to the truth. The word believe by itself does not carry
with it the connotation of obedience.
The connotation of obedience or the lack thereof comes from the context
as is the case in the above verse of scriptures, for we know that demons do not
obey God.
For that reason the meaning of the word believe depends on the
context in which it is used.
We
need to understand that belief is viewed in scriptures from two perspectives,
that of God and that of man. There were
occasions in scriptures where Jesus viewed man s belief from both God s
perspective and man s perspective. We
are going to find out from scriptures which perspective we should use in
discerning whether the belief in specific passages of scriptures refers to
faith or not. Jesus is the one who is
going to judge the living and the dead; he is the one who is going to grant
salvation based on whether a person has faith in him or not. We need to pay attention to what he declared
as faith because that will be the criterion that will be used on the day of judgment.
Let s first take a look at how belief is viewed from God s perspective
in scriptures and then we ll do it from man s perspective.
Jn 2:23 Now while he was
in Jerusalem at the Passover Feast, many people saw the miraculous signs he was
doing and believed in his name.
Jn 2:24 But Jesus would
not entrust himself to them, for he knew all men.
Jn 2:25 He did not need
man s testimony about man, for he knew what was in a man.
As God, Jesus
knew all men and what was in a man. He
could see through these people who believed in his name and knew that their
belief was mere mental assent - he was viewing their belief as mere mental
assent from God s perspective.
Jn 6:64 Yet there are some of you who do not
believe. For Jesus had known from the beginning which of
them did not believe and who would betray him.
Judas was the one
who did not believe. He certainly had
provisioned mental assent before Jesus.
As God, Jesus knew from the beginning that Judas belief was mere mental
assent and that Judas would betray him.
He was viewing Judas unbelief and eventual conduct from God s
perspective.
In the context of
the above two passages of scriptures Jesus viewed man s belief as mere mental assent
from God s perspective.
Jn 8:30 Even as he
spoke, many put their faith in him.
Jn 8:31 To the Jews who
had believed him, Jesus said, If you hold to my teaching, you are really my
disciples.
Jn 8:32 Then you will
know the truth, and the truth will set you free.
Jesus viewed the
belief of these people who believed in him primarily as mental assent because
their being his disciples was contingent upon their holding to his teaching in
the course of time for lack of outward evidence right at the moment of
assessment. It would take time for them
to demonstrate their obedience to his teachings in deeds. In other words Jesus was basing the
assessment of discipleship and faith on outward evidence in the course of time
and not on a onetime declaration of mental assent. The translation of faith in verse 30 should
actually be belief instead, which would make the translation more neutral and
consistent with the context. In the
context of this passage of scriptures Jesus viewed man s belief primarily as
mental assent from man s perspective since his assessment of discipleship and
faith was based on outward evidence in the course of time and not on his
insight as God ahead of time.
So at times Jesus
viewed man s belief as mere mental assent from God s perspective; at other
times he viewed man s belief as mere mental assent from man s perspective. While he would at times view from God s
perspective a person s belief as mere mental assent, when it came to declaring
that a person had faith, Jesus always based his declaration on evidence without
exception as recorded in scriptures.
Mk 2:1 A few days
later, when Jesus again entered Capernaum, the people heard that he had come
home.
Mk 2:2 So many gathered that there was no room left, not even
outside the door, and he preached the word to them.
Mk 2:3 Some men came, bringing to him a paralytic, carried by four
of them.
Mk 2:4 Since they could
not get him to Jesus because of the crowd, they made an opening in the roof
above Jesus and, after digging through it, lowered the mat the paralyzed man
was lying on.
Mk 2:5 When Jesus saw
their faith, he said to the paralytic, Son, your sins
are forgiven.
There
was always a clear context indicative of faith with real people in a live
situation in scriptures when Jesus rendered a positive assessment of
faith. Never in scriptures would Jesus assess
that a person had faith without basis on evidence in the context. The above passage of scriptures is such an
example and the gospel accounts carry a number of such assessments. In fact Jesus
commendation of those who had great faith, chiding of those who had little and
condemnation of those who had none was always based on evidence or the lack
thereof. He never made such declarations
in scriptures without basing them on evidence or the lack thereof. So Jesus consistently viewed man s
belief as faith from man s perspective in scriptures.
Thus far we have
established the following concerning how Jesus viewed man s belief as recorded
in scriptures:
At times Jesus viewed man s belief as
mere mental assent from God s perspective; at other times he viewed man s
belief as mere mental assent from man s perspective.
Jesus consistently viewed man s belief as
faith from man s perspective; he did not view man s belief as faith from God s
perspective.
Unlike Jesus who
is God, we as mere humans would have no way of telling whether a person s
belief is mere mental assent during a brief encounter with the person, nor can
we tell that a person s belief is faith without basis on any outward evidence indicative
of faith. The reality is that not even
Jesus himself would view man s belief as faith from God s perspective. We should only view man s belief the way
Jesus would that we as humans are capable of doing if we are to be his
followers. That would include the
following:
Viewing man s belief as mere mental
assent from man s perspective.
Viewing man s belief as faith from man s
perspective.
Consequently we
cannot view man s belief from God s perspective, i.e., without basis on
evidence or the lack thereof; we can only view man s belief from man s
perspective, i.e., based on evidence or the lack thereof. Viewing man s belief from God s perspective
is out of scope for man; viewing man s belief from man s perspective is in
scope. On the other hand there are mere
humans in scriptures who seemed capable on occasions of viewing man s belief as
faith from God s perspective.
Ac 14:8 In Lystra there sat a man crippled in his feet, who was lame
from birth and had never walked.
Ac 14:9 He listened to
Paul as he was speaking. Paul looked directly at him,
saw that he had faith to be healed
Ac 14:10 and called out, Stand up on your feet!
At that, the man jumped up and began to walk.
Paul s
declaration of the crippled man s faith without basis on outward evidence is
very rare in scriptures and done from God s perspective. Please
note that no one can perceive that a person has faith if that person is doing
nothing more than provisioning mental assent while listening to the preaching
of the good news. Paul was able to perceive the crippled man s faith without relying on any outward
evidence other than perhaps some visual cues from the man as mental
assent. He was able to because he was
filled with the Holy Spirit at the moment and so had the insight that he
otherwise would not have. He was right
in his assessment of the crippled
man s faith since the man obeyed the Holy Spirit s bidding given through
him and tried to get up. Though he could
not get up by himself, the crippled man was healed while he was trying to as an
expression of his willingness to obey and was then able to.
We as regular believers can only go by outward
evidence in a live situation for the confirmation of faith. We
cannot presume that we can do what Paul did while he was filled with the Holy
Spirit at the point of healing the crippled man. When we claim we can, we are claiming
something that cannot be validated. Such
a claim in declaring a person s inevitable eternal destiny in heaven without basis
on any outward evidence in that person s circumstance other than mere mental
assent to the good news of Jesus Christ is so prevalent at the present day as
to qualify it to be among the most damning deceptions for keeping countless
people on course in their headlong plunge into the fire of hell, while giving
them the assurance that they are on an inexorable course heading for
heaven.
If we are not in a position to declare man s belief as
faith without basis on outward evidence indicative of faith in a live situation, it is the same when it comes to interpreting passages in
scriptures that are descriptions on paper. Evidence in the context is all that we can go
by. When we interpret belief in
scriptures as faith without basis on evidence in the context, we are claiming
some sort of insight that is not based on evidence in the context alone. As mere humans, no one can refute the claim. But it does fall outside the scope of an
objective and consistent approach in interpreting scriptures.
With what has been said, the question arises as to
what constitutes legitimate evidence for the declaration of faith in a live
situation and the interpretation of belief as faith in the context of
scriptures, if not belief as in mere mental assent to the good news of Jesus
Christ. Let s examine relevant passages
in scriptures and find out.
Heb 11:8 By faith Abraham, when called to go to a place he would
later receive as his inheritance, obeyed and went, even though he did not know
where he was going.
According to this verse of
scriptures faith is a sufficient condition that is causal for obedience in
deeds. This makes obedience in deeds a
necessary condition for faith. In other words, without obedience in deeds faith does not
exist.
Heb 11:31 By faith the prostitute Rahab,
because she welcomed the spies, was not killed with those who were disobedient.
According to this verse of
scriptures faith is a sufficient condition that is causal for obedience in
deeds. This makes obedience in deeds a necessary condition for faith. In other words,
without obedience in deeds faith does not exist.
Jas 2:17 In the same way, faith by itself, if it is not accompanied
by action, is dead.
Jas 2:18 But someone will
say, You have faith; I have deeds. Show me your faith without deeds, and I
will show you my faith by what I do.
Deeds are
portrayed to be a necessary condition for faith in verse 17 and a sufficient
condition in verse 18. In the Book of
James believers are urged to obey instructions in scriptures to do good deeds
which can be described as obedience in deeds.
Jas
1:22 Do not merely listen to the word, and so deceive
yourselves. Do what it says.
Because obedience
in deeds is the sufficient condition for faith, where there is obedience in
deeds, there is faith - obedience in deeds is an indicator for faith. In fact it is not just an indicator for faith
but rather the indicator for faith because obedience in deeds is not just a
sufficient condition for faith but also a necessary condition as shown above. Being the sufficient and necessary condition
for faith makes obedience in deeds the one and only indicator for faith.
We
can come to the conclusion that
it is obedience in deeds and not mere mental assent to the good news of Jesus
Christ that constitutes the legitimate
evidence for the declaration of faith in a live situation and the interpretation
of belief as faith in the context of scriptures. With
such a conclusion let s see how obedience in deeds is applied as the indicator
for faith in interpreting scriptures.
Jn 9:35 Jesus heard that
they had thrown him out, and when he found him, he said, Do you believe in the
Son of Man?
Jn 9:36 Who is he,
sir? the man asked. Tell me so that I may believe in him.
Jn 9:37 Jesus said, You
have now seen him; in fact, he is the one speaking with you.
Jn 9:38 Then the man said, Lord, I believe, and
he worshiped him.
The belief in
verse 38 is faith because it is accompanied by obedience in deeds in
worshipping Jesus.
Ac 19:18 Many of those
who believed now came and openly confessed their evil deeds.
Ac 19:19 A
number who had practiced sorcery brought their scrolls together and burned them
publicly. When they calculated the value of the scrolls, the total came to
fifty thousand drachmas.
The belief in verse 18 is faith because it is accompanied by the confession of sins
and obedience in deeds in rejecting sorcery at great costs.
Ge 15:4 Then the word of the LORD
came to him: This man will not be your heir, but a son coming from your
own body will be your heir.
Ge 15:5 He took him
outside and said, Look up at the heavens and count the stars if indeed you can
count them. Then he said to him, So shall your offspring be.
Ge 15:6 Abram believed
the LORD, and he credited it to
him as righteousness.
The belief in verse 6 is faith because
Abraham had been obeying God for ten years in coming to and living in
Canaan. He had already exhibited a
consistent pattern of obedience in deeds indicative of faith. This was only an occasion for him to renew
his faith in God for God s promise for him.
2Co 4:13 It is written: I believed; therefore I have spoken. With
that same spirit of faith we also believe and therefore speak,
2Co 4:14 because we know
that the one who raised the Lord Jesus from the dead will also raise us with
Jesus and present us with you in his presence.
The spirit of faith encompasses
not only belief as in mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ but also
being vocal about the good news. Someone
can believe as in provisioning mental assent to the good news but would never
say a word to make known the good news to others because he does not have
faith. The belief in verse 13 is faith
because it is accompanied by obedience in deeds in testifying to the good news.
By this time we have established that belief should be
interpreted as faith in the context of scriptures when it is accompanied by
obedience in deeds. The same goes with
declaration of faith in a live situation - it is obedience in deeds that is the
legitimate indicator that a person s belief is faith. What if there is no reference to obedience in
deeds in the context in a passage of scriptures? Is the belief in that passage of necessity mere
mental assent?
Jn 2:22 After he was raised from the dead, his disciples recalled
what he had said. Then they believed the Scripture and the words that Jesus had
spoken.
Jn 2:23 Now while he was
in Jerusalem at the Passover Feast, many people saw the miraculous signs he was
doing and believed in his name.
Jn 2:24 But Jesus would
not entrust himself to them, for he knew all men.
Jn 2:25 He did not need
man s testimony about man, for he knew what was in a man.
When Jesus was
crucified, the faith of his disciples evaporated. But they had their faith restored, renewed
and strengthened as they witnessed scriptures being fulfilled through Jesus
resurrection. The belief in verse 22 was
faith. Therefore belief in scriptures
can be faith even when it is not accompanied by obedience in deeds, if the
context indicates it. We have previously
examined verses 23-25 of the above passage of scriptures and concluded that in
accordance with the context the belief in verse 23 is mere mental assent.
The above passage of scriptures is quoted
from the gospel of John. If you do a
search, you will find that the gospel of John uses the word believe more than
any other book in the New Testaments. If
you care to count, it exceeds even the total number of times it is used in the
other gospel accounts. John juxtaposed
the two different usages of the word in the beginning - Chapter 2 - of his
gospel account to encourage his readers to examine the context to find out
about the intended meaning of each usage.
Please note that John was an evangelist who was keen on discerning what
people meant when they said they believed, unlike the prevalent present-day practice
of indiscriminately associating belief with faith without reference to reality. We need to develop proper discernment for
mere mental assent, something that is more than mental assent and faith. But what do we mean by something that is more
than mental assent?
Jn 7:37 On the last and greatest day of the Feast, Jesus stood and
said in a loud voice, If anyone is thirsty, let him come to me and drink.
Jn 7:38 Whoever believes in me, as the Scripture has said, streams
of living water will flow from within him.
Jn 7:39 By this he meant the Spirit, whom those who believed in him
were later to receive. Up to that time the Spirit had not been given, since
Jesus had not yet been glorified.
Eph 1:13 And you also were included in Christ when you heard the word
of truth, the gospel of your salvation. Having believed, you were marked in him
with a seal, the promised Holy Spirit,
Eph 1:14 who
is a deposit guaranteeing our inheritance until the redemption of those who are
God s possession to the praise of his glory.
The belief in the above two passages
of scriptures is more than mere mental assent because it is a sufficient
condition that is causal for regeneration by the Holy Spirit and redemption in
the context. Please note that it takes
more than mental assent from a person for the Holy Spirit to regenerate him as
seen in the following verses of scriptures:
Ac
2:37 When the people heard this, they were cut to the heart
and said to Peter and the other apostles, Brothers, what shall we do?
Ac 2:38 Peter replied,
Repent and be baptized, every one of you, in the name of Jesus Christ for the
forgiveness of your sins. And you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.
It takes repentance
in addition to the declaration of mental assent to the good news of Jesus
Christ by way of baptism for a person to receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. Therefore the belief
in the two aforementioned passages of
scriptures John 7:37-39 and Ephesians 1:13-14 is more than mere mental
assent. In other words belief in
scriptures can be more than mere mental assent even when it is not accompanied
by obedience in deeds, if the context indicates it.
Jn 6:47 I tell you the
truth, he who believes has everlasting life.
Jn 20:31 But these are
written that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that
by believing you may have life in his name.
The belief in the above two verses of
scriptures leads to the possession of eternal life in
the context and is therefore more than mere mental assent. It takes more than mere mental assent
to the good news of Jesus Christ from a person for him to receive eternal life
as seen in the following passage of scriptures.
1Ti 6:17
Command those who are rich in this present world not to be arrogant nor to put
their hope in wealth, which is so uncertain, but to put their hope in God, who
richly provides us with everything for our enjoyment.
1Ti 6:18 Command them to do good, to
be rich in good deeds, and to be generous and willing to share.
1Ti 6:19 In this way they will lay up
treasure for themselves as a firm foundation for the coming age, so that they
may take hold of the life that is truly life.
The people referred to in this passage of scriptures
are believers because the command is for believers. It takes obedience in deeds in addition to
mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ to take hold of the life that is
truly life in the coming age. Therefore the belief in the two
aforementioned verses of scriptures - John 6:47 and John 20:31 - is more than
mere mental assent. In other words
belief in scriptures can be more than mere mental assent even when it is not
accompanied by obedience in deeds, if the context indicates it.
1Co 1:21 For since in the wisdom of God the world through its wisdom
did not know him, God was pleased through the foolishness of what was preached
to save those who believe.
The belief in this verse of
scriptures is more than mere mental assent because it
leads to salvation in the context. It
takes more than mere mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ from a
person for him to be saved as seen in the following passage of scriptures:
Mt 24:9 Then you will
be handed over to be persecuted and put to death, and you will be hated by all
nations because of me.
Mt 24:10 At that time many will turn away from the faith and will
betray and hate each other,
Mt 24:11 and many false
prophets will appear and deceive many people.
Mt 24:12 Because of the
increase of wickedness, the love of most will grow cold,
Mt 24:13 but he who stands firm to the end will
be saved.
It takes standing firm to the end in the face of
persecution even to the point of death in addition to provisioning mental
assent to the good news of Jesus Christ for a person to be saved. Therefore the belief in the aforementioned
verse of scriptures 1 Corinthians 1:21 is more than mere mental
assent. In other words belief in
scriptures can be more than mere mental assent even when it is not accompanied
by obedience in deeds, if the context indicates it.
Jn 4:39 Many
of the Samaritans from that town believed in him because of the woman s
testimony, He told me everything I ever did.
Jn 4:40 So when the Samaritans came to him, they urged him to stay
with them, and he stayed two days.
Jn 4:41 And because of his words many more became believers.
Jn 4:42 They
said to the woman, We no longer believe just because of what you said; now we
have heard for ourselves, and we know that this man really is the Savior of the
world.
The belief in
verse 39 refers to mental assent of some sort about Jesus that was driven
mainly by the Samaritans curiosity because of the woman s testimony, though it
was accompanied by their earnestness in inviting Jesus to stay with them in
order to find out more about him. The
belief in verse 41 likely depicts the point of their initial willingness to
obey Jesus word. It refers to mental
assent nevertheless because there is no reference to obedience in deeds or
evidence indicative of faith in the context, only mental assent that might be accompanied
by willingness to obey as seen in their expressed conviction about Jesus after
they had heard from him themselves.
Anyhow only someone who had lived among the Samaritans and had witnessed
a consistent pattern of obedience in deeds among them would be able to attest
to their faith. Faith
can only be observed in the course of time and not during a brief occasion of
evangelism. Apart from that there
is no way to confirm it in the context of the above passage though there was a
fair likelihood that they might have been granted the gift of faith.
1Th 3:4 In
fact, when we were with you, we kept telling you that we would be persecuted. And it turned out
that way, as you well know.
1Th 3:5 For this reason, when I could stand it no longer, I sent to
find out about your faith. I was afraid that in some way the tempter might have
tempted you and our efforts might have been useless.
1Th 3:6 But
Timothy has just now come to us from you and has brought good news about your
faith and love. He has told us that you always have pleasant memories of us and
that you long to see us, just as we also long to see you.
1Th
3:7 Therefore, brothers, in all our distress and persecution
we were encouraged about you because of your faith.
Paul sent to find
out about the Thessalonian believers faith because they
suffered for it. He was concerned that
their faith might not have endured under the circumstance. If we look at the beginning of this epistle
to the Thessalonians, we find the following passage:
1Th 1:4 For we know, brothers loved by God, that he has chosen you,
1Th
1:5 because our gospel came to you not simply with words, but
also with power, with the Holy Spirit and with deep conviction. You
know how we lived among you for your sake.
1Th 1:6 You became imitators of us and of the Lord; in spite of
severe suffering, you welcomed the message with the joy given by the Holy
Spirit.
1Th 1:7 And so you became a model to all the believers in Macedonia
and Achaia.
1Th 1:8 The
Lord s message rang out from you not only in Macedonia and Achaia your faith in
God has become known everywhere. Therefore we do not need to say anything about
it,
1Th 1:9 for
they themselves report what kind of reception you gave us. They tell how you
turned to God from idols to serve the living and true God,
1Th
1:10 and to wait for his Son from heaven, whom he raised from
the dead Jesus, who rescues us from the coming wrath.
Verse
4 says that Paul and his team of workers knew that the Thessalonian
believers had been chosen by God. Verse
5 says that the gospel came to them with power, with the Holy Spirit and with
deep conviction. Verse 8 says that their
faith in God had become known everywhere.
Regardless of all these, Paul sent to find out about their faith because
he was afraid that the efforts of his team among the Thessalonians might have
been useless. In Paul s thinking
knowledge of people s being elected by God for salvation was one thing and
their having enduring faith was another.
It points to the reality that Paul had doubt about his assessment of
their election and finding out about the evidence of their enduring faith was
the only way to confirm it. This says
enough about the necessity of establishing a consistent pattern of obedience in
deeds in the course of time for the confirmation of faith.
Ac 13:6 They traveled through the whole island until they came to Paphos. There they met a Jewish sorcerer and false prophet
named Bar-Jesus,
gAc 13:7 who was an attendant of the
proconsul, Sergius Paulus.
The proconsul, an intelligent man, sent for Barnabas and Saul because he wanted
to hear the word of God.
Ac 13:8 But Elymas the sorcerer (for that is what his name means)
opposed them and tried to turn the proconsul from the faith.
Ac 13:9 Then Saul, who
was also called Paul, filled with the Holy Spirit, looked straight at Elymas and said,
Ac 13:10 You are a child
of the devil and an enemy of everything that is right! You are full of all
kinds of deceit and trickery. Will you never stop perverting the right ways of
the Lord?
Ac 13:11 Now the hand of
the Lord is against you. You are going to be blind, and for a time you will be
unable to see the light of the sun. Immediately mist and darkness came over
him, and he groped about, seeking someone to lead him by the hand.
Ac 13:12 When the
proconsul saw what had happened, he believed, for he was amazed at the teaching
about the Lord.
The proconsul sent for Barnabas and Paul
because he wanted to hear the word of God.
Though he had a heart that was inclined to hear the truth, it is not
certain that it had to do with faith because there is no reference to obedience
in deeds in the context. His belief appeared
to be mental assent that was accompanied by the desire to hear the truth. The translation of faith in verse 8 is
problematic on that account and should have been belief instead. The proconsul had his belief strengthened at
the end of the episode for what had transpired and the word of truth that
Barnabas and Paul had spoken. On the
other hand it remained uncertain as to whether it could be characterized as faith
for lack of obedience in deeds at the moment.
Only someone who had been in the company of the proconsul for a
significant period of time and had witnessed a consistent pattern of obedience
in deeds would be able to attest to his faith.
Please note that faith implies mental assent but mental assent
does not imply faith. It is appropriate
to be cautious and interpret belief as mental assent by default and not faith
because mental assent is the lowest common denominator. It is only when the context requires the
belief to be interpreted as faith for the sake of evidence that it should
be. The context can depict a progression
of the strengthening of belief that might ultimately lead to faith though not necessarily
in the particular context that is being examined, as seen in the above two
passages of scriptures. This is the appropriate
way of interpretation for the word belief because faith requires a context
for its validation while the default meaning of mental assent does not. In other words the meaning of the word does
not drive the interpretation of the context but rather the context drives the
interpretation and translation of the word.
In light of what has been
discussed we come to the conclusion that belief in the context of scriptures refers
to faith when it is accompanied by obedience in deeds or when there is evidence
indicative of faith in the context. The
same goes with the declaration of faith in a live situation it is obedience
in deeds that is the legitimate indicator that a person s belief is faith. Furthermore belief in the context of scriptures can be more than mere
mental assent even when it is not accompanied by obedience in deeds, if the
context indicates it. On the other
hand such characterization of belief may not be as easily applicable in a live
situation because written descriptions in scriptures can provide the indication
from the scripture writer s perspective as seen above that might not be
available in a live situation.
Next we are going
to examine an issue with the translation of the word belief in
scriptures. The noun form of the word is
routinely translated in the English bible as faith. Based on the above discussion it can be
problematic. Fortunately most of the
time, it is consistent with the context though on some occasions it is
problematic as has been seen. On other
occasions it can literally change our understanding of the mechanics of
salvation in a way that is not consistent with scriptures.
Gal 3:2 I would like to learn just
one thing from you: Did you receive the Spirit by observing the law, or by
believing what you heard?
In the original
language the noun form of the word belief is used. Unlike the other instances of problematic
translation of the word in the NIV mentioned earlier, the NIV makes no apparent
attempt to translate the word belief as faith for the above verse and instead
uses the verb form in the translation that is less biased for faith. That is appropriate because the belief in
this verse is not faith for lack of obedience in deeds at the point of
receiving the Holy Spirit in the context, though it is more than mere mental
assent as discussed earlier because regeneration by the Holy Spirit is
involved.
Please note that
the Galatians were trying to observe the Jewish law in contradiction to Paul s
instructions to them for salvation. Obedience
in deeds and observing the law are two different things, the former being
submissive to the truth, which is God-centric, while the latter being
legalistic, which is egocentric. Had it referred
to faith, the belief would have been accompanied by obedience in deeds or
evidence indicative of faith in the context, particularly at the moment of
receiving the Holy Spirit which is the focal point of Paul s rhetorical
question.
The NIV is a less
literal and therefore less accurate translation than the King James version. For a change
it has perhaps a more appropriate translation for this verse that might not
have been intended by the translator.
Galatians 3:2
(King James Version)
2 This only would
I learn of you, Received ye the Spirit by the works of the law, or by the
hearing of faith?
The translation of
the word belief as faith in this verse in the King James version is
problematic because there is no reference to obedience in deeds or evidence
indicative of faith at the point of receiving the Holy Spirit in the context,
even though we know that the belief is more than mere mental assent as
discussed earlier because it leads to regeneration by the Holy Spirit. It is problematic also because faith is
portrayed as the cause of regeneration by the Holy Spirit thus eliminating
regeneration from the causal chain of deliverance from bondage to sin, even
though regeneration is a necessary condition that is causal for deliverance
discussed earlier.
Indeed the end
portion of the causal chain of deliverance from bondage to sin has turned from
being regeneration by the Holy Spirit causative-immediately preceding the
granting of the gift of faith which in turn causative-immediately precedes deliverance,
to being faith causative-immediately preceding deliverance. Regeneration has become incidental and not
causal to deliverance from bondage to sin contrary to what Jesus told Nicodemus
in John 3:3-6 that was examined earlier.
This way of translating the word belief into a meaning other than the
default lowest common denominator allows the translation and interpretation of
the word to drive the interpretation of the context instead of the other way
round, which is wrong for this particular word.
The translation
of the word is problematic also because it implies that man can have faith
prior to regeneration by the Holy Spirit.
As we have already seen earlier in this sub-study, Jesus is the sole
author of faith and the Holy Spirit the sole source of faith granted to
man. And faith is the gift of God to man
of the supernatural proportion that man cannot have prior to regeneration by
the Holy Spirit. It is therefore wrong
to translate the word belief as faith in the above verse of scriptures.
We must not lose
sight of the spiritual reality that faith is the gift of God granted to man
unto salvation that man cannot conceive in the discussion of the mechanics of
salvation. Man s belief as in mental
assent to the good news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by obedience in
deeds is not faith but indicative of the faith that has been granted him. As we shall see in the next section, a person s mental assent to the good news that is
accompanied by repentance causatively precedes his being regenerated, granted
the gift of faith and delivered from bondage to sin by the Holy Spirit.
This is how we make a proper distinction
between mental assent which belongs in the earthly realm and is of earthly
composition, and faith which belongs in the spiritual realm and is of the
supernatural proportion. Without the
distinction we cannot interpret the word belief properly in the context of
scriptures. With the distinction we let
the context drive the interpretation of the word so that it can take up the
appropriate meaning among the various possibilities that fits in with the
context. Because the context drives the
interpretation of the word, it is inevitable that it also drives the
translation. That is when the literal
approach in translation could break down because the meaning of a word is
rigidly fixed and hence rigidly drives the interpretation of the context, and
when a more interpretive approach could avail.
It avails particularly in the context of identifying the mechanics of
salvation. Without proper distinction
between mental assent and faith in the context of scriptures, it is impossible
to properly assign the role God and man play in man s salvation resulting from
a hopelessly entangled mishmash of the meaning of the word belief .
We
should also look at the interpretation and usage of the word belief from a
historical perspective. With belief in Jesus came persecution in the first
century but it is not necessarily so at the present day. It was less likely that people would
haphazardly provision mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ that was
not accompanied by repentance and hence willingness to obey God then than it is
at the present day. As a matter of fact
people these days are more likely to be encouraged to provision mental assent without
the accompanying repentance and willingness to obey God. Not surprisingly their belief is oftentimes
nothing more than mere mental assent. If
we strictly apply the word belief recorded in scriptures in the first century
to the present day without regard to the historical context, it can be a
misapplication because circumstance has changed. We need to let the historical context drive
the interpretation of the word in scriptures and at the same time not rigidly fix
its meaning when applying it to the present-day context.
One
would ask if such an approach for interpreting and translating the words
believe and belief is justifiable. Please
note that whether this particular approach is justifiable or not, making a
distinction between belief as in mental assent and belief as referring to faith
is still necessary and inevitable because even demons can believe. We certainly do not want to mistake the mental
assent of demons for faith. Furthermore
if every instance of the words believe and belief should be interpreted as
intended for faith by default regardless of the context, the question arises as
to how we are going to make a distinction between faith that saves and mere mental
assent that does not.
It is
particularly problematic when the scriptural context where these words are used
obviously points to the absence of faith.
If faith should be the interpretation when scripture writer explicitly
pointed out the absence of faith in the context, is faith then nothing more
than mental assent? And why do we even
need the Holy Spirit for our possession of faith when the unregenerate is
capable of provisioning mental assent? What
then is the difference between our so-called faith and the belief of
demons? And why are countless people who
attend church plunging headlong into the fire of hell for their failure to
produce fruit in keeping with repentance if provisioning mental assent to the
good news of Jesus Christ alone will save them?
It attests to our failure in the proper and accurate formulation of the
doctrine of salvation for hundreds of years.
Would we not be held accountable before God for mishandling the eternal
welfare of many? Claiming that God did
not elect them for salvation before the creation of the world is not going to
absolve us because God has not foreordained our failure.
If we
are not bold in injecting clarifying ideas into the debate over the doctrine of
salvation, the stalemate in the debate will persist indefinitely as it has for
the past hundreds of years. It will continue
to leave open the opportunity for all sorts of misleading and fatal belief to
persist in the context of salvation. Furthermore
where bible translation has fallen short, it needs to be improved upon. No one has come up with a perfect translation
yet in case that is not obvious. Claiming
inerrancy for certain translations is tantamount to claiming that one has come
up with a model of salvation that has no possibility of being wrong and more.
In
summary belief should be interpreted as mental assent by default because mental
assent is the lowest common denominator of belief that does not require a
context for its validation. Belief should be interpreted as faith when it is accompanied
by obedience in deeds or evidence indicative of faith in the context. Belief can be more than mere mental
assent even when it is not accompanied by obedience in deeds in scriptures, if
the context indicates it. Otherwise
belief should be interpreted as mere mental assent. That is how the
context drives its interpretation and translation. Anyway this is what we should customarily do
in real life. When a person says that he
believes in Jesus, we should not simply think that he is a follower of Jesus
Christ who has been regenerated by the Holy Spirit and therefore has been
granted the gift of faith. Rather we
would find out in real-life situations whether he would consistently exhibit a
pattern of obedience in deeds indicative of faith before we would come to the conclusion
that he indeed has been regenerated and therefore has faith in his possession.
Belief as in mental assent to the good
news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by repentance causatively precedes regeneration, the granting of the
gift of faith and deliverance from bondage to sin by the Holy Spirit with
regeneration, the granting of the gift of faith and deliverance being
chronologically synchronous and regeneration causative-immediately preceding
the granting of the gift of faith, which in turn causative-immediately precedes
deliverance
We have come to the
understanding that belief in scriptures can be more than mere mental assent
even when it is not accompanied by obedience in deeds, if the context indicates
it. Such belief can lead to regeneration by the
Holy Spirit, salvation, the possession of eternal life as we have seen
earlier. In this section we are going to investigate what the
belief might entail in addition to mental assent.
Ac 2:38
Peter replied, Repent and be baptized, every
one of you, in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins. And
you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.
Baptism
is a public declaration of mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ. Mental assent that is accompanied by
repentance is shown here to be a cause for God to grant the gift of the Holy
Spirit. Alternatively mental assent to
the good news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by repentance is a cause on a
causal chain of regeneration by the Holy Spirit.
We have
just established the following:
1.
Mental assent to the good news of Jesus
Christ that is accompanied by repentance is a cause on a causal chain of
regeneration by the Holy Spirit.
Previously
we have come to the following conclusion:
2.
Repentance causatively precedes
deliverance from bondage to sin.
3.
Regeneration, the granting of the gift of faith and
deliverance from bondage to sin by the Holy Spirit are chronologically
synchronous, with regeneration causative-immediately preceding the granting of
the gift of faith, which in turn causative-immediately precedes deliverance.
Please
note that we can add an extra fulfilled condition to #2 for it to say the
following that is true:
Mental
assent to the good news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by repentance
causatively precedes deliverance from bondage to sin.
This
is legitimate because #2 subsumes the above statement. In fact any extra fulfilled condition can be
added and the new statement would be subsumed by #2 and therefore true. The findings can now be stated as follows:
1.
Mental assent to the good news of Jesus
Christ that is accompanied by repentance is a cause on a causal chain of
regeneration by the Holy Spirit.
2.
Mental assent to the good news of Jesus
Christ that is accompanied by repentance causatively precedes deliverance from
bondage to sin.
3.
Regeneration, the granting of the gift of faith and
deliverance from bondage to sin by the Holy Spirit are chronologically
synchronous, with regeneration causative-immediately preceding the granting of
the gift of faith, which in turn causative-immediately precedes deliverance.
#2
stipulates that mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ that is
accompanied by repentance is a cause on the only causal chain of deliverance
from bondage to sin in accordance with the convention in the current sub-study. #3 stipulates that regeneration and the
granting of the gift of faith are causes on the only causal chain of deliverance
from bondage to sin again in accordance with the convention in the current
sub-study. #2 and #3 together stipulate
that mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by repentance, regeneration and the granting of the gift of
faith are causes on the only causal chain of deliverance from bondage to
sin. #1 further determines mental assent
to the good news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by repentance to be a more
intermediate cause than regeneration in that causal chain. In accordance with the convention of this
sub-study we can state the following:
Belief as in mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ
that is accompanied by repentance causatively precedes regeneration, the granting of the
gift of faith and deliverance from bondage to sin by the Holy Spirit with regeneration,
the granting of the gift of faith and deliverance being chronologically
synchronous and regeneration causative-immediately preceding the granting of
the gift of faith, which in turn causative-immediately precedes deliverance.
Provisioning mental assent to the good
news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by repentance is man s responsibility;
granting the gift of faith through regeneration of man by the Holy Spirit in
order to deliver him from bondage to sin is God s. The biblical protocol for man to receive
regeneration, the granting of the gift of faith and deliverance from bondage to
sin is provisioning mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ that is
accompanied by repentance. That is what Jesus called on man to do when he
began his ministry.
Mk 1:14 After John was
put in prison, Jesus went into Galilee, proclaiming
the good news of God.
Mk 1:15 The time has
come, he said. The kingdom of God is near. Repent and believe the good news!
Everyone can believe as in provisioning
mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ.
Some refuse to provision
mental
assent because they do not want to believe that they are sinners in need of
repentance for their salvation. Some provision mental assent without the
accompanying repentance and willingness to obey and so do not receive the gift
of the Holy Spirit and faith and are not delivered from bondage to sin. The rest provision mental assent with the accompanying repentance and
willingness to obey and therefore receive the gift of the Holy Spirit and faith
and are delivered from bondage to sin.
For a
sanity check let s take a look at the passage of scriptures:
Ac 16:27 The jailer woke up, and when he saw the prison doors open,
he drew his sword and was about to kill himself because he thought the
prisoners had escaped.
Ac 16:28 But
Paul shouted, Don t harm yourself! We are all here!
Ac 16:29 The jailer called for lights, rushed in and fell trembling
before Paul and Silas.
Ac 16:30 He then brought
them out and asked, Sirs, what must I do to be saved?
Ac 16:31 They replied, Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be
saved you and your household.
The
jailer demonstrated repentance and willingness to obey when he did not want to
kill himself any more but instead asked what he must do to be saved. Paul and Silas, sensing the spirit of
repentance and the spirit of obedience that was in him, urged him to believe,
i.e., provision mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ. The guarantee was that belief as in mental
assent to the good news that was accompanied by repentance and willingness to
obey would lead to the jailer s salvation, which can refer to the onetime event
of deliverance from bondage to sin or the lifelong process of salvation. Please note that the onetime event of deliverance from bondage to
sin inaugurates the lifelong process of salvation. Therefore belief as in mental assent to the
good news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by repentance leads to
deliverance from bondage to sin, which is consistent with the findings above.
Next we are going to examine
a passage of scriptures that will help demonstrate what has been discussed. Before we do that, let s reiterate the
foundational truth of salvation in scriptures.
Ro 3:28 For we maintain
that a man is justified by faith apart from observing the law.
Man is justified by faith
alone meaning that faith causative-immediately precedes justification in accordance with
the convention in the current sub-study.
Ro 3:22 This righteousness from God comes through faith in Jesus
Christ to all who believe. There is no difference,
Ro 3:23 for all have
sinned and fall short of the glory of God,
Ro 3:24 and are justified freely by his grace
through the redemption that came by Christ Jesus.
The translation of the word
faith is appropriate in verse 22 because being made righteous and being
justified by God are causative-immediately preceded by faith. The translation of the word believe in the
same verse is also appropriate and should be interpreted as provisioning more
than mere mental assent because it leads to faith but does not itself refer to
faith. Indeed it should be interpreted
as provisioning mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ that is
accompanied by repentance in light of the total context of scriptures. Such a translation and interpretation of
verse 22 is consistent with what has been discussed in this section and
adequately accounts for the hint in this verse that faith and belief might
belong in two different categories of matter.
Unbelief leads to the
blinding of the mind of an unbeliever by the god of this age and the
non-granting of the gift of faith by God
While the foregoing
discussion illustrates what happens chronologically and causally when a person
repents and provisions mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ, 2
Corinthians 4:3-6 illustrates what happens chronologically and causally when a
person does not.
2 Corinthians 4:3-6 (Young's
Literal Translation)
3 and
if also our good news is vailed, in those perishing
it is vailed,
4 in
whom the god of this age did blind the minds of the unbelieving, that there
doth not shine forth to them the enlightening of the good news of the glory of
the Christ, who is the image of God;
5 for
not ourselves do we preach, but Christ Jesus -- Lord, and ourselves your
servants because of Jesus;
6 because
[it is] God who said, Out of darkness light [is] to shine, who did shine in our
hearts, for the enlightening of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face
of Jesus Christ.
Verse 4 indicates that when a
person does not believe, the god of this age blinds his mind so that the light
of the good news of the glory of Christ does not shine forth to him. Please note that it does not say that the
mind of a person is blinded by the god of this age so that he cannot believe;
rather it is when he does not believe that his mind is blinded so that the
light does not shine forth. Please also
note that verse 6 makes it clear that it is God who does the shining forth of
the light in the hearts of those who believe.
As long as a person remains unbelieving, his mind will continue to be
blinded by the god of this age that the light will continue not to shine forth
to him. But when he believes, the god of
this age can no longer blind his mind, with the consequence that the light of
the good news inevitably shines forth.
The above passage
of scriptures demonstrates the other side of the mechanics of salvation such
that unbelief leads to the god of this age blinding the mind of the
unbelieving, which then leads to God not shining forth the light of the good
news of Jesus Christ to them. One
wonders what the unbelief refers to such that when a person holds to the
unbelief, the god of this age would blind his mind that the light does not
shine forth to him. Please note that the
unbelieving refers to those who do not provision mental assent to the good news
that Jesus is their savior. But that is
not all that there is to say about their unbelief. When a person does not provision mental
assent that Jesus is his savior, he does not provision mental assent that he is
a sinner in need of repentance for his salvation, let alone salvation through
faith in Jesus. In other words the
unbelieving refers to the unrepentant.
When a person
believes (that he is a sinner in need of repentance for his salvation), the god
of this age can no longer blind his mind with the consequence that God shines
forth to him the light of the good
news. To be more specific, when a person
repents and is willing to obey God, the god of this age cannot get in the way
with the consequence that the Holy Spirit regenerates him, grants him the gift
of faith and delivers him from bondage to sin.
When we say that
a person stops believing, we are in reality saying that he stops repenting and
is no longer willing to obey God after having been regenerated by the Holy
Spirit, granted the gift of faith and delivered from bondage to sin. The god of this age can again blind his mind
with the consequence that the light of the good news no longer shines forth to
him any more, which is the equivalent of the Holy Spirit withdrawing his
indwelling and ceasing granting him the gift of faith and so he has shipwrecked
his faith. It is not that God is unable
to keep the person believing but that it is in God s implementation plan of
man s salvation that the Holy Spirit s continual indwelling and granting man
the gift of faith is contingent upon man s continual repentance and willingness
to obey as we shall see in a later section.
That repentance is an integral part of man s salvation is implied in the
context a few verses prior to the above passage of scriptures:
2 Corinthians 3:14-16 (Young's
Literal Translation)
14 but
their minds were hardened, for unto this day the same vail
at the reading of the Old Covenant doth remain unwithdrawn
-- which in Christ is being made useless --
15 but
till to-day, when Moses is read, a vail upon their
heart doth lie,
16 and
whenever they may turn unto the Lord, the vail is
taken away.
Verse 16 makes it clear that
the veil is taken away when a person turns to the Lord rather than that the
veil is taken away so that the person can turn to the Lord. In other words the person turning to the Lord
is a cause leading to the effect of the veil being taken away. Please note that turning to the Lord means
turning to him in repentance and willing obedience. No one can turn to the Lord without
repentance and willing obedience; anyone who turns to the Lord must be
repenting and willing to obey. So when a
person turns to the Lord in repentance and willing obedience, the god of this
age cannot blind his mind thus resulting in the veil being taken away and the
light of the good news shining forth to him, which is the Holy Spirit regenerating
him, granting him the gift of faith and delivering him from bondage to sin.
All these
squarely put on man the responsibility for repentance and willingness to obey
the good news of Jesus Christ, on the god of this age the responsibility for
blinding the mind of unrepentant sinners, and on God the responsibility for
shining forth the light of the good news of Jesus Christ unto all such that
whosoever believes (that he is a sinner in need of repentance for his
salvation) is regenerated by the Holy Spirit and granted the gift of faith and
thus seeing the light of the glory of the good news. Such a relationship between mental assent,
repentance, non-repentance, the blinding of the mind and faith in the context
of salvation properly accounts for the biblical evidence in 2 Corinthians 4:3-6. It explains why God still needs to shine
forth the light of the good news unto a person when he believes (that he is a
sinner in need of repentance for his salvation). When we fail to factor the accompaniment of
repentance with mental assent into the discussion of the mechanics of
salvation, we cannot properly account for all the biblical evidence. Mental assent that is accompanied by repentance
is the biblical protocol for receiving regeneration and the granting of the
gift of faith by the Holy Spirit and key to understanding the mechanics of
salvation.
Though he is willing, a
repentant person is not able to escape the destruction of sin on his own; God
has to deliver him, which is a sovereign act of God.
Ro 7:14 We know that the law is spiritual; but I am unspiritual,
sold as a slave to sin.
Ro 7:15 I do
not understand what I do. For what I want to do I do not do, but what I hate I
do.
Ro 7:16 And if I do what I do not want to do, I agree that the law
is good.
Ro 7:17 As it is, it is no longer I myself who do it, but it is sin
living in me.
Ro 7:18 I
know that nothing good lives in me, that is, in my
sinful nature. For I have the desire to do what is good, but
I cannot carry it out.
Ro 7:19 For what I do is not the good I want to do; no, the evil I
do not want to do this I keep on doing.
Ro 7:20 Now
if I do what I do not want to do, it is no longer I who do it, but it is sin
living in me that does it.
Ro 7:21 So I find this law at work: When I want to do good, evil is
right there with me.
Ro 7:22 For in my inner being I delight in God s law;
Ro 7:23 but
I see another law at work in the members of my body, waging war against the law
of my mind and making me a prisoner of the law of sin at work within my
members.
Ro 7:24 What a wretched man I am! Who will rescue me from this body
of death?
Ro 7:25 Thanks be to God through
Jesus Christ our Lord! So then, I myself in my mind am a slave to God s law,
but in the sinful nature a slave to the law of sin.
Verse 14 establishes the
point of reference that is prior to a person s deliverance from bondage to sin
because he is sold as a slave to sin. If we look a number of
verses back, we would find the following two verses that confirm that a person
who is a slave to sin has not been delivered from bondage to sin.
Ro 6:17 But
thanks be to God that, though you used to be slaves to sin, you wholeheartedly
obeyed the form of teaching to which you were entrusted.
Ro 6:18 You
have been set free from sin and have become slaves to righteousness.
Romans 6:17-18
indicates that a person who is a slave to sin has not yet obeyed the good news
of Jesus Christ and that once he has obeyed, he has been delivered from bondage
to sin. In other words a person who is a
slave to sin has yet to be delivered from bondage to sin.
Consequently Romans 7:14-25
quoted above refers to the reality of a person who has not been delivered from
bondage to sin because he is sold as a slave to sin. This passage of scriptures points out the
inability of a man controlled by the sinful nature to submit to God s law and
to do what it requires. It is true that
man by his own strength cannot fulfill the requirement of God s law. On the other hand it also points out that man
can desire and can be willing to do what the law requires even though he is
unable to do it by his own strength. When
a man controlled by the sinful nature finds himself doing not the good that he
wants to do, but the evil that he does not want to do, he comes to the
realization that he is wretched and in need of deliverance and that he is unable
to deliver himself by his own strength. This
passage clearly shows that man controlled by the sinful nature can be willing
to obey what the law requires even though by his own strength he cannot because
of his bondage to sin.
Man is therefore able to
choose good over evil even though he would fall short in terms of doing good as
Paul made clear. Not being able to do good does not mean not being able to choose good; there is a
difference between doing good and choosing good. It is like a drug addict who knows that drug
is destroying him and wants to quit but could not; he wants to do what is good
but could not do it. Such a person would
repent when he hits rock bottom and turns to God for deliverance because he is
desperate knowing that he cannot deliver himself from the evil. He might not be able to quit taking drug on
his own but he could choose good and be willing to
turn to God for deliverance.
Lot was willing to leave Sodom as seen in
his frantically trying to convince his sons-in-law to leave the city. But when it came time for him to leave, he
lingered because he was entangled with the pleasures of Sodom. He could not just extricate himself and his
family from the pleasures of Sodom and hence the destruction of Sodom on his
own. It took more than being willing to
leave to leave in deed. But because he
was willing, the angels brought him and his family out of the destruction of
Sodom. He was delivered from the
destruction not because he heeded the angels advice for him to leave but by a
power outside of himself. In the same
way the Israelites were delivered form bondage in Egypt through miracles. They could not just leave on their own even
though they were willing to. It took
more than being willing to leave to leave in deed. But because they were willing, God delivered
them out of Egypt. It is willingness to
obey that counts in God sight.
When a person first repents, he becomes willing to turn away from sin
but cannot do it yet because being willing is not enough for him to extricate
himself from bondage to sin. It takes
more than willingness to leave the bondage of sin to leave in deed. But because he is willing, he is indwelled,
regenerated and granted the gift of faith by the Holy Spirit. Indwelling,
regeneration and the granting of the gift of faith by the Holy Spirit is the
supernatural work of God that delivers a person from bondage to sin - man can
do nothing to deliver himself. It enables him to truly turn away
from sin and sets him on running the course of salvation. With faith in his possession he can begin to
obey in deeds beyond mere willingness to obey.
Therefore willingness to obey comes from man s repentance while
obedience in deeds comes from faith granted as the gift from God. It is God granting repentant sinners
their wish to obey him.
Mk 2:5 When Jesus saw
their faith, he said to the paralytic, Son, your sins
are forgiven.
Mk 2:6 Now some teachers of the law were sitting there, thinking to
themselves,
Mk 2:7 Why does this
fellow talk like that? He s blaspheming! Who can forgive sins but God
alone?
Mk 2:8 Immediately Jesus knew in his
spirit that this was what they were thinking in their hearts, and he said to
them, Why are you thinking these things?
Mk 2:9 Which is easier: to say to the paralytic, Your sins are
forgiven, or to say, Get up, take your mat and walk ?
Mk 2:10 But that you may
know that the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins . . . . He
said to the paralytic,
Mk 2:11 I tell you, get
up, take your mat and go home.
Mk 2:12 He got up, took his mat and walked out
in full view of them all. This amazed everyone and they praised God, saying,
We have never seen anything like this!
The
paralytic was unable to get up and walk by himself. Please note that Jesus did not cause him to
get up and walk. He had the spirit of obedience
and was willing to do what Jesus commanded even though he was unable to by his
own strength. But because he was
willing, Jesus healed him while he was trying to get up so that he could obey
in deeds. That is how it is with us when
we have the spirit of repentance and the spirit of obedience, and are willing
to obey God even though by our own strength we are unable to obey in
deeds. But because we are willing, God
grants us our wish to obey him by granting us the gift of faith so that we can
obey in deeds.
God provisions for the
elect the root cause, the preceding and independent part of the intermediate
cause and the immediate cause while man the subsequent and dependent part of
the intermediate cause on the only causal chain of deliverance from bondage to
sin
Please note that
the discussion of the causal chain of deliverance from bondage to sin in this
section is in the context of the deliverance of the elect those whom God
elected to receive salvation before the creation of the world. As noted earlier a person can shipwreck his faith
after he has been regenerated by the Holy Spirit, granted the gift of faith and
delivered from bondage to sin. The
current discussion of the causal chain of deliverance from bondage to sin does
not apply to such a person.
The causal chain
of man s deliverance from bondage to sin in its simplest form has a root cause,
an intermediate cause and an immediate cause.
God is the gatekeeper of salvation.
He provisions the root cause through the grand design of election before
the creation of the world and the immediate cause through regeneration and the
granting of the gift of faith by the Holy Spirit in the implementation plan of
his grand design. We have come to this
understanding of the root cause in the study on election; we have come to this
understanding of the immediate cause in the current sub-study. God also provisions in the implementation
plan of his grand design the preceding and independent part of the intermediate
cause that makes it possible for man to provision the subsequent and dependent part
of the intermediate cause through mental assent to the good news of Jesus
Christ that is accompanied by repentance.
We have come to this understanding of God s and man s contribution to
the intermediate cause in the current sub-study.
The causal chain of
deliverance from bondage to sin can be summarized in chronological order as
follows:
God
provisions in the grand design of election the root cause before the creation
of the world.
God
provisions in the implementation plan of his grand design the preceding and
independent part of the intermediate cause that makes it possible for man to
provision the subsequent and dependent part of the intermediate cause through
mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by
repentance.
God
provisions in the implementation plan of his grand design the immediate cause
through regeneration and the granting of the gift of faith by the Holy Spirit.
The root cause in
the causal chain of deliverance from bondage to sin comes under God s grand
design of election. The intermediate
cause and the immediate cause come under God s implementation plan of his grand
design. Please note the following about
the causal chain of deliverance from bondage to sin:
God
is the sole provider of the root cause.
God
and man together are the joint provider of the
intermediate cause.
God
is the sole provider of the immediate cause.
A member
of the elect is delivered from bondage to sin when the causal chain of deliverance
is fulfilled in his personal setting.
Because of God s
preceding contribution to the intermediate cause in making it possible for man
to repent in order to receive forgiveness, man can choose to contribute to the
intermediate cause or choose not to. If
man can only choose to because such a choice is inevitable as a result of God s
direct intervention in him, then God and not man is the one that does the
provisioning in reality. Then God would
be the sole provider in the entire causal chain of man s deliverance from
bondage to sin without man making any contribution to the intermediate cause at
all. It is only when the choice for
provisioning the dependent part of the intermediate cause rests with man that
he can be a provider in the causal chain.
It is with that understanding that we characterize man s provisioning
part of the intermediate cause in the causal chain of deliverance from bondage
to sin.
As concluded from
the study on election, God s grand design of election as the root cause of
salvation is unconditional because it took place before the creation of the
world beyond the scope of man s participation.
It is unconditional and deterministic from God s perspective. On the other hand God s implementation plan
of his grand design is contingent upon man s repentance and willingness to
obey. It is conditional and
non-deterministic from man s perspective.
The unconditional and deterministic nature of God s grand design of
election does not contradict the conditional and non-deterministic nature of
his implementation plan. God is
sovereign in his grand design of election while man is responsible for his
repentance and willingness to obey the good news of Jesus Christ in the
implementation plan. God s grand design
and his implementation plan do not intersect and belong in different realms. The God-provisioned root cause in his grand
design and the man-provisioned dependent part of the intermediate cause in the
implementation plan of his grand design are not tightly coupled.
That is to say,
God s provisioning the root cause does not necessarily obviate man s
contribution to the intermediate cause.
Alternatively speaking, God s grand design of election does not dictate
the specifics of the implementation plan of his grand design and only
guarantees its outcome. In fact God can choose from among a collection of
implementation plans to accomplish his grand design, whether God being the sole
provider, man being the sole provider, or God and man together being the joint
provider of the intermediate cause in the causal chain of man s deliverance from
bondage to sin.
Ac 13:48 When
the Gentiles heard this, they were glad and honored the word of the Lord; and
all who were appointed for eternal life believed.
Please note that appointment
for eternal life is God s election and the root cause in the causal chain of deliverance. Belief is man s contribution to the dependent
part of the intermediate cause in the causal chain. Please consider the following statement:
Everyone who is invited to
the event has duly arrived.
This statement relates the arrival
of invitees to the event as anticipated but makes no reference as to how they
travel to the location of the event. It
can be through mechanized means of travel such as plane, train, car, bus,
non-mechanized means such as travelling on foot, or both. There is no restriction on the means of
travel to the location at all in the context.
In the same way the above
verse of scriptures places no restriction on how one comes to believe, whether
the cause of belief is entirely due to God, entirely due to man, partly due to
God and partly due to man, or even some other possibilities. God s appointment
for eternal life as the root cause of deliverance from bondage to sin only
guarantees the eventual outcome of belief in this verse; it does not
necessarily dictate that God has to provide the sole enablement for belief. In other words ascription of the root cause
in the causal chain of deliverance to God as the sole provider does not rigidly
require that God also be the sole provider of the intermediate cause and hence
the sole provider in the entire causal chain.
Provisioning of the root cause and provisioning of the intermediate
cause are not tightly coupled such that God being the sole provider of the root
cause does not rule out the possibility of man being a partial provider of the
intermediate cause.
The intermediate cause in the
causal chain of deliverance from bondage to sin is the driving factor in God s
implementation plan of his grand design of election. Providers of the intermediate cause play a part
in driving the implementation plan. But
whoever the provider of the intermediate cause is, whether God being the sole
provider, man being the sole provider, or God and man together being the joint
provider, God does not look across realms and base his election decision in the
realm of his grand design on man s eventual input in the realm of his
implementation plan in order to serve as man s time-reversed proxy before the
creation of the world. If God does, it becomes
an instance of the effect influencing the cause in a causal chain, which is
contradictory to the causal relationship.
Election is of necessity a unilateral decision on God s part and
therefore unconditional. What he elects
as his grand design, it shall be in the end as the inevitable outcome of his
implementation plan even though man might exercise his free will to participate
in and influence the implementation process.
Otherwise it is not election at all.
Ro 9:19 One of you will say to me: Then why does God still blame us?
For who resists his will?
Ro 9:20 But who are you,
O man, to talk back to God? Shall what is formed say to him who formed it,
Why did you make me like this?
We
need to acknowledge man s limitation as God s creation and God s sovereignty in
the unconditional election of man for his salvation and not attempt to reason
around it. It
is futile for man to attempt to cross over into the realm of God s grand design
of election that took place before the creation of the world and argue from
that perspective. Let s refrain from
doing that and simply accept God s sovereignty in the election of man for his
salvation and our God-ordained limitation as his creation.
Therefore when we say that
provisioning of the root cause and provisioning of the intermediate cause are not
tightly coupled, it applies both ways such that the sole party (God) that
provisions the root cause does not inevitably have to be the sole party (God)
that provisions the intermediate cause, and that the party (man) that partially
provisions the intermediate cause does not influence the root cause through a
time-reversed proxy in the party (God) that provisions the root cause.
There is a widespread attempt
in the debate over the doctrine of salvation to tightly couple the provisioning
of the root cause and the provisioning of the intermediate cause. Those who adhere to certain extreme positions
would claim that since God is the sole provider of the root cause, God must
also be the sole provider of the intermediate cause and hence the sole provider
in the entire causal chain of deliverance from bondage to sin. And those who adhere to certain middle
positions would claim that though man is only a partial provider of the
intermediate cause, he can actually influence the provisioning of the root
cause through God as the time-reverse proxy before the creation of the
world. The reality is that such tight
couplings are unfounded in the context of salvation in scriptures as discussed
earlier.
We
must resist tightly coupling the realm of God s grand design of election and
the realm of God s implementation plan of his grand design and instead focus
more on the implementation plan that is in scope for man, where the
intermediate cause and the immediate cause of the causal chain of deliverance
from bondage to sin operate. It makes
good common sense for us to have our feet planted on firm ground and not try to
cross realms into the space of God s grand design before the creation of the
world that is in scope only for God.
Otherwise we would only be using God as the excuse to push our ideology
which can have no way of being validated.
Now
that we have examined the relationship between the root cause and the
intermediate cause in the causal chain of deliverance from bondage to sin,
let s take a look at the relationship between the intermediate cause and the
immediate cause. As a result of God s
preceding provision of the independent part of the intermediate cause that
makes it possible for man to repent, it becomes possible for man to make
subsequent contribution to the dependent part of the intermediate cause through
mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by
repentance. Such a fulfilled
intermediate cause will lead to the immediate cause of regeneration and the granting
of the gift of faith by the Holy Spirit, which leads to the end effect of man s
deliverance from bondage to sin of the causal chain. Deliverance from bondage to sin makes him a
legitimate candidate for salvation and sets him on running the course of
salvation.
Issue #3: What are the roles of God
and man in the lifelong process of man s salvation post deliverance from
bondage to sin?
In regard to issue #3 we are
going to validate the following from scriptures:
Continuing to repent and to be willing to obey instructions in
scriptures post deliverance from bondage
to sin is the responsibility of the person who has been delivered, not God s.
Provisioning repentance and willingness to obey
instructions in scriptures for running the course of salvation is not about man
working for his salvation.
Deliverance from the ultimate destruction of sin at the
end of the age and obedience in deeds throughout life are the peer end effects
of the causal chain of salvation as a lifelong process.
Continuing to repent and to be willing to obey instructions
in scriptures post deliverance from bondage to sin is the responsibility of the
person who has been delivered, not God s.
The sub-study for validation
of findings pertaining to issue #1 presented in the study entitled A
Functional Model of Salvation , namely,
Is salvation a onetime event
or is it a lifelong process?
has reached the
conclusion that salvation is a lifelong process the outcome of which is
determined at the end of a person s running the course of salvation post deliverance
from bondage to sin and not cast in concrete at the point of the person s deliverance
as a onetime event. This in turn makes
the preceding repentance, willingness to obey instructions in scriptures, faith
and the subsequent obedience in deeds a process each in its own right.
As concluded earlier in the current
sub-study, obedience in deeds is the one and only indicator for faith and
consequently the one and only indicator for repentance also. Proving our repentance and faith by our
obedience in deeds is a process and not an event. It demonstrates that we are the legitimate
candidates for running the course of salvation and for receiving salvation when
Jesus returns. The following passages
are some of the criteria in scriptures for ascertaining the proof of repentance
and faith. They all pertain to a process
and not an event and duly refer to the context of man s running the course of
salvation.
Mt 24:9 Then you will
be handed over to be persecuted and put to death, and you will be hated by all
nations because of me.
Mt 24:10 At that time many will turn away from the faith and will
betray and hate each other,
Mt 24:11 and many false
prophets will appear and deceive many people.
Mt 24:12 Because of the
increase of wickedness, the love of most will grow cold,
Mt 24:13 but he who
stands firm to the end will be saved.
Jn 8:31 To the Jews who
had believed him, Jesus said, If you hold to my teaching, you are really my
disciples.
Jn 8:32 Then you will
know the truth, and the truth will set you free.
Jn 8:51 I tell you the
truth, if anyone keeps my word, he will never see death.
Jn 15:6 If anyone does not remain in me, he is like a branch that is
thrown away and withers; such branches are picked up, thrown into the fire and
burned.
Jn 15:10 If you obey my
commands, you will remain in my love, just as I have obeyed my Father s
commands and remain in his love.
Ro 8:13 For if you live according to the sinful nature, you will
die; but if by the Spirit you put to death the misdeeds of the body, you will
live,
Ro 8:14
because those who are led by the Spirit of God are sons of God.
1Co 15:2 By this gospel
you are saved, if you hold firmly to the word I preached to you. Otherwise, you
have believed in vain.
1Ti 4:16
Watch your life and doctrine closely. Persevere in them, because if you do, you
will save both yourself and your hearers.
1Ti 6:12 Fight the good fight of the
faith. Take hold of the eternal life to which you were called when you made
your good confession in the presence of many witnesses.
1Ti 6:18 Command them to do good, to
be rich in good deeds, and to be generous and willing to share.
1Ti 6:19 In this way they will lay up
treasure for themselves as a firm foundation for the coming age, so that they
may take hold of the life that is truly life.
2Ti 4:7 I
have fought the good fight, I have finished the race, I have kept the
faith.
2Ti 4:8 Now
there is in store for me the crown of righteousness, which the Lord, the
righteous Judge, will award to me on that day and not only to me, but also to
all who have longed for his appearing.
Heb 3:6 But Christ is faithful as a
son over God s house. And we are his house, if we hold on to our courage and
the hope of which we boast.
Heb 3:14 We
have come to share in Christ if we hold firmly till the end the confidence we
had at first.
1Jn 2:3 We
know that we have come to know him if we obey his commands.
1Jn 2:24 See that what you have heard
from the beginning remains in you. If it does, you also will remain in the Son
and in the Father.
The above passages of
scriptures show that salvation is a process the outcome of which is contingent
upon our action and attitude to the very end.
It is our personal responsibility and not God s for us to take hold of
eternal life after we have been delivered from bondage to sin. If we pay attention to the warnings and
exhortations and obey the instructions conveyed in passages of scriptures such
as these, we have furnished proof of our repentance and faith and will receive
salvation when Jesus returns. If we pay
no attention to the warnings and exhortations and disobey the instructions, we have
no proof for our repentance and faith and will not receive salvation. Obeying instructions in scriptures like these
for running the course of salvation is the criterion for receiving salvation
because they are the proper proof of our repentance and faith.
Jesus has perfect obedience to God and
does not need to repent in order to foment the spirit of obedience. That was why John the Baptist came before
Jesus to exemplify repentance. We have
less than perfect obedience because of our ongoing entanglement with the
pleasures of sin that relentlessly drives us toward disobedience. Therefore we need to continually repent and continually
foment the spirit of obedience if we desire to walk in Jesus steps to obey
God. Continual repentance and continual
willingness to obey instructions in scriptures is the cause for the Holy Spirit
to continually grant us the gift of faith post deliverance from bondage to sin
so that we can continue to obey in deeds while running the course of salvation,
which is the proof of our repentance and faith.
Heb 6:4 It is impossible for those who have once been enlightened,
who have tasted the heavenly gift, who have shared in the Holy Spirit,
Heb 6:5 who have tasted
the goodness of the word of God and the powers of the coming age,
Heb 6:6 if they fall
away, to be brought back to repentance, because to their loss they are
crucifying the Son of God all over again and subjecting him to public disgrace.
Because these people could not be brought back to
repentance, we know that they must have repented previously. In fact verses 4 and 5 are a most fitting description of those who
have been regenerated by the Holy Spirit and have been granted the gift of
faith for their repentance. And yet they
can cease to repent and cease being willing to obey instructions in scriptures,
thus resulting in the Holy Spirit ceasing granting them the gift of faith
they have shipwrecked their faith.
Shipwrecking our faith is not an overnight event. God will prod us through the Holy Spirit and circumstances
in life for us to repent and to turn back to him, and to renew our willingness
to obey instructions in scriptures. But
if we harden our hearts and refuse to repent for the sake of the temporary
pleasures of sin, our hearts become calloused and less sensitive to the
prompting of the Holy Spirit. When the
pattern of repentance is broken, we have abandoned the spirit of obedience and can
no longer respond to the prompting of the Holy Spirit. We will no longer renew our willingness to
obey instructions in scriptures and the Holy Spirit will withdraw his
indwelling and cease granting us the gift of faith - we have shipwrecked our
faith. We must therefore never cease repenting
and never cease being willing to obey instructions in scriptures lest we fall
away. We must pay particular attention
to repentance and willingness to obey as we run the course of salvation.
Repentance is like the immune system of the
body that continually destroys mutant cells before they could proliferate and
develop into cancer. Repentance is not
just a onetime event but a way of life for the church for the ongoing health of
the church. Upon our repentance and willingness
to obey instructions in scriptures, God will take care of the rest. Sometimes we are so fixated on faith that is
granted solely by the Holy Spirit that we have neglected repentance and willingness
to obey instructions in scriptures that we must provision in order to be
granted the gift of faith. The reality
is that no one can summon up faith from within; it is the gift of God. If we do our part to repent and to be willing
to obey, God will do his part to grant us the gift of faith. Let s be earnest and repent and trust God for
the gift of faith that he will grant as we repent and are willing to obey.
Just as faith is granted anew moment by
moment, righteousness is a process and not an event because righteousness comes
through faith.
Ro 3:22 This righteousness from God comes through faith in Jesus
Christ to all who believe. There is no difference,
Ro 3:23 for all have
sinned and fall short of the glory of God,
Ro 3:24 and are
justified freely by his grace through the redemption that came by Christ Jesus.
Righteousness comes through faith in
Jesus Christ. Since faith is granted
continually, we are made righteous also continually. But aren t our sins dealt with once and for
all before God when we provision mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ
that is accompanied by repentance, are regenerated, granted the gift of faith
and delivered from bondage to sin by the Holy Spirit? Doesn t Jesus blood cover over our sins once
and for all so that God does not see them any more when we sin? No, God sees them, so does the devil. In fact the devil makes accusations against
us before God day and night for every sin we commit.
Rev 12:10 Then I heard a
loud voice in heaven say: Now have come the salvation and the power and the
kingdom of our God, and the authority of his Christ. For the accuser of our
brothers, who accuses them before our God day and night, has been hurled down.
The devil makes accusation of sins
against every believer day and night before God.
Ro 8:33 Who will bring any charge against those whom God has chosen?
It is God who justifies.
Ro 8:34 Who is he that condemns? Christ Jesus, who died more than
that, who was raised to life is at the right hand of God and is also
interceding for us.
In response to the devil s continual accusation
Jesus continually intercedes before God in our defense for every sin we
commit. We keep the devil and Jesus very
busy with our perpetual sinning. It is
Jesus continual interceding before God in our defense against the devil s
continual accusation that keeps us continually righteous before God. Every time the devil makes an accusation and
produces evidence of our sins before God, Jesus introduces his blood as
evidence in our defense. We would be
unable to defend ourselves against the devil s continual accusation without
Jesus continual interceding.
Heb 7:23 Now there have
been many of those priests, since death prevented them from continuing in
office;
Heb 7:24 but because
Jesus lives forever, he has a permanent priesthood.
Heb 7:25 Therefore he is
able to save completely those who come to God through him, because he always
lives to intercede for them.
Because he always lives to intercede for
them, Jesus is able to save completely those who come to God through him. The implication is that if he does not
continually intercede for them, Jesus cannot completely save them even though
he might have delivered them from bondage to sin at the point of their initial
repentance. It is essential that Jesus
continually intercedes for them before God for their complete salvation.
1Jn 2:1 My dear children, I write this to you so that you will not
sin. But if anybody does sin, we have one who speaks to the Father in our
defense Jesus Christ, the Righteous One.
1Jn 2:2 He is the atoning sacrifice
for our sins, and not only for ours but also for the sins of the whole world.
Verse 1 again alludes to the fact that
Jesus speaks to the Father in our defense for every sin we commit. Because he died for the sins of the whole
world, Jesus is the atoning sacrifice for the sins of the whole world. Upon his death on the cross the sins of the
whole world were atoned for once and for all.
On the other hand the benefit of the atonement is not applied once and
for all at the time when Jesus atoned for the sins of the whole world once and
for all. Rather it is continually being
applied as Jesus intercedes before God on behalf of believers.
Heb 10:26 If
we deliberately keep on sinning after we have received the knowledge of the
truth, no sacrifice for sins is left,
Heb 10:27 but only a fearful
expectation of judgment and of raging fire that will consume the enemies of
God.
Even though Jesus died and atoned for the
sins of the whole world once and for all, we as believers can still forfeit the
benefit of his atonement when we deliberately keep on sinning. That is the basis for saying that the benefit
of Jesus atonement is not applied once for all at the point of atonement but
being applied continually.
But what is the basis for Jesus
continual interceding before God in our defense? Is it because we have been regenerated,
granted the gift of faith and placed in Christ such that there is now no
condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus (Romans 8:1)? Yes and no.
We are cleansed from every sin we commit not simply because of the
position we are in once we have been regenerated, granted the gift of faith and
placed in Christ, but also because of our continual repentance and continual
willingness to obey instructions in scriptures post regeneration that allow us
to remain in that position. Continual
repentance is how we can continue to be granted the gift of faith, continue to
remain in Christ and continue to come under his protection against the devil s
accusation before God. That is how we
can continue to enjoy the benefit of Jesus atonement for our sins. It is worthwhile to again review the
following passage of scriptures:
Heb 6:4 It is impossible for those who have once been enlightened,
who have tasted the heavenly gift, who have shared in the Holy Spirit,
Heb 6:5 who have tasted
the goodness of the word of God and the powers of the coming age,
Heb 6:6 if they fall
away, to be brought back to repentance, because to their loss they are
crucifying the Son of God all over again and subjecting him to public disgrace.
The people
referred to in this passage of scriptures have been regenerated, granted the
gift of faith, delivered from bondage to sin and placed in Christ in accordance
with the depiction of their condition.
But when they fall away and cannot be brought back to repentance, they
have forfeited the privilege of repentance, will no longer be granted the gift
of faith and can no longer remain in Christ.
Jesus will stop interceding before God in their defense against the
devil s accusation they have forfeited the benefit of Jesus atonement for
their sins and will perish in their own sins.
Jn 15:6 If anyone does not remain in me, he is like a branch that is
thrown away and withers; such branches are picked up, thrown into the fire and
burned.
Being in Christ
does not give us the license to sin at all.
Instantaneous righteousness is nothing but a self-delusional excuse for
those who want to indulge themselves the pleasures of sin without
accountability.
2Pe 2:20 If they have
escaped the corruption of the world by knowing our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ
and are again entangled in it and overcome, they are worse off at the end than
they were at the beginning.
2Pe 2:21 It would have
been better for them not to have known the way of righteousness, than to have
known it and then to turn their backs on the sacred command that was passed on
to them.
The people
referred to in this passage of scriptures have forfeited the benefit of Jesus
atonement for their sins. Their lot would
become worse at the end because they turned their backs on the sacred command
than at the beginning when they did not yet know Jesus. In addition those who have never repented can
still choose to repent and to be willing to obey the good news of Jesus Christ
such that they can enjoy the benefit of Jesus atonement for their sins. But those who have forfeited the benefit of
Jesus atonement for their sins can never be brought back to repentance and can
never receive the benefit again. Consequently
they can never again be justified and made righteous before God - they will
perish in their own sins. This is the
ongoing state of affairs for the church until Jesus returns, once and for all
roots up everything that causes sins and brings us to eternal life. Until then we have no final peace and rest as
long as it remains possible for us to sin and fall away.
But some of us object
to the process-driven nature of being justified and made righteous before God
by quoting Hebrews 10:14 and claim that Jesus atoning sacrifice on the cross
has once and for all made perfect and righteous before God those sanctified.
Hebrews 10:14 (Young's Literal Translation)
14 for by one offering he hath perfected to the end
those sanctified.
The context of verse 14 can be found in verses 1-14.
Hebrews 10:1-14 (Young's Literal Translation)
1 For the law having a shadow of the coming good
things -- not the very image of the matters, every year, by the same sacrifices
that they offer continually, is never able to make perfect those coming near,
2 since, would they not have ceased to be offered,
because of those serving having no more conscience of sins, having once been
purified?
3 but in those [sacrifices] is a remembrance of sins
every year,
4 for it is impossible for
blood of bulls and goats to take away sins.
5 Wherefore, coming into the world, he saith, `Sacrifice and offering Thou didst not will, and a
body Thou didst prepare for me,
6 in burnt-offerings, and concerning sin-offerings,
Thou didst not delight,
7 then I said, Lo, I come, (in a volume of the book it
hath been written concerning me,) to do, O God, Thy will;'
8 saying above -- `Sacrifice, and offering, and
burnt-offerings, and concerning sin-offering Thou didst not will, nor delight
in,' -- which according to the law are offered --
9 then he said, `Lo, I come to do, O God, Thy will;'
he doth take away the first that the second he may establish;
10 in the which will we are having been sanctified
through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once,
11 and every priest, indeed, hath stood daily serving,
and the same sacrifices many times offering, that are never able to take away
sins.
12 And He, for sin one sacrifice having offered -- to
the end, did sit down on the right hand of God, --
13 as to the rest, expecting till He may place his
enemies [as] his footstool,
14 for by one offering he hath perfected to the end
those sanctified.
Verse 14 is for the purpose of making a sharp contrast
with verses 1-2 that while animal sacrifice though made repeatedly is unable to
make perfect those coming near, Jesus atoning sacrifice on the cross though
made once only is able to make perfect to the end those sanctified. The focus of the contrast is on the futility
and ineffectiveness of the multiplicity of animal sacrifice made continually and
the efficiency and efficacy of the singularity of Jesus atoning sacrifice made
once and for all in regard to perfection that the respective sacrifice renders.
If we look a number of verses further in chapter 10,
we find verses 26-29.
Hebrews 10:26-29 (Young's Literal Translation)
26 For we -- willfully sinning after the receiving the
full knowledge of the truth -- no more for sins doth there remain a sacrifice,
27 but a certain fearful looking for of judgment, and
fiery zeal, about to devour the opposers;
28 any one who did set at nought
a law of Moses, apart from mercies, by two or three
witnesses, doth die,
29 of how much sorer punishment shall he be counted
worthy who the Son of God did trample on, and the blood of the covenant did
count a common thing, in which he was sanctified, and to the Spirit of the
grace did despite?
In response to
the objection to the process-driven nature of being justified and made
righteous before God, first we are going
to establish that verse 14 cannot be interpreted literally without the
underlying assumption for this verse having been taken into consideration. For the causal chain of deliverance from
bondage to sin that we have been discussing, Jesus atoning sacrifice on the
cross is assumed to have been made and is considered a fulfilled
condition. That is why it does not show
up in the causal chain of deliverance from bondage to sin. That being the case, mental assent to the
good news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by repentance is the sufficient
and necessary condition that leads to the granting of the gift of faith by the
Holy Spirit, which is the sufficient and necessary condition that leads to
deliverance from bondage to sin.
If we factor Jesus atoning sacrifice into the causal
chain of deliverance from bondage to sin, then mental assent to the good new of
Jesus Christ that is accompanied by repentance is only a necessary condition
that leads to the granting of the gift of faith, which is only a necessary
condition that leads to deliverance, with Jesus atoning sacrifice itself as yet
another necessary condition in the causal chain. Jesus atoning sacrifice as a necessary
condition together with mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ that is
accompanied by repentance as another necessary condition constitute the
sufficient and necessary condition that leads to the granting of the gift of
faith by the Holy Spirit. And Jesus
atoning sacrifice as a necessary condition together with the granting of the
gift of faith by the Holy Spirit as yet another necessary condition constitute
the sufficient and necessary condition that leads to deliverance from bondage
to sin.
When all these factors including Jesus atoning
sacrifice are taken into consideration in the causal chain of deliverance from
bondage to sin, no one single factor can by itself constitute a sufficient
condition for deliverance. That being
the case, certain conditions must be assumed to have been fulfilled in the
context of verse 14 for Jesus atoning sacrifice to have perfected or made righteous
before God to the end those sanctified. In
other words verse 14 must not be interpreted literally without the underlying
assumption having been taken into consideration. We must first investigate and understand the underlying
assumption for this verse before we can render its proper interpretation in
context.
If we interpret verse 14 as meaning that Jesus
atoning sacrifice made once has perfected or made righteous before God to the
end those sanctified, the interpretation would be out of place in the total
context of the Book of Hebrews. The
writer of Hebrews consistently lays out the final condition of destruction for
a person who has been regenerated, granted the gift of faith and delivered from
bondage to sin and yet later on ceases to repent and hence shipwrecks his
faith. Such a person was sanctified through
Jesus atoning sacrifice at one point in time as made clear in verses 26-29 and
would continually be sanctified in a sanctification process through the
sacrifice thereafter as verse 10 indicates.
In fact verses 26-29 present a direct conflict with verse 14 in that the
former states that a person who was once sanctified could later on reject
Christ such that he would no longer be sanctified and made righteous before God
through the sacrifice and so faces eternal destruction.
Since verses 26-29 constitute a declaration of an
absolute and exclusive position on the final condition of the apostate, there
is no room for adjustment for the interpretation of these verses. On the other hand we have established that
verse 14 must not be interpreted literally without the underlying assumption of
this verse having been taken into consideration. Thus there is room for adjustment for its
interpretation in order to bring it into alignment with verses 26-29 and with
the total context of the Book of Hebrews.
Since Jesus atoning sacrifice has perfected (perfect
tense, active voice, indicative mood that states that something has indeed
occurred in Greek) to the end those sanctified as stated in verse 14 and that
cannot be adjusted, we need to identify the underlying assumption in its reference
to those sanctified. It should be
assumed that those sanctified (present tense, passive voice, participle in
Greek) as referred to in verse 14 have their ongoing sanctification process sustained
to the end with the consequence that Jesus atoning sacrifice has indeed once
and for all perfected them to the end.
That would fully draw out the potency of Jesus atoning sacrifice in
contrast to animal sacrifice that needs to be offered continually without
actually perfecting those coming near. That
would be consistent with the intent of scripture writer to make a sharp
contrast between the two.
On the other hand such potency is tempered by and by
this time consistent with verses 26-29 that make it clear that a person who is
at the moment sanctified through Jesus atoning sacrifice may later on reject
Christ and so no longer be sanctified through the sacrifice. This interpretation of verse 14 also makes it
consistent with the total context of the Book of Hebrews. In other words Jesus atoning sacrifice
potent as it is does not in itself sustain a sanctified person s sanctification
to the end; rather its sustenance depends on other factors such as the person s
continual repentance. When other factors
such as refusal to continue to repent work to halt the sanctification process,
the sacrifice that was previously effective for the person now becomes
nullified.
The devil has
indeed been defeated by Jesus when Jesus was crucified for our sins and then
raised to life. But we as our own
greatest enemy can do ourselves in while running the course of salvation after
we have been delivered from bondage to sin and placed in Christ. Remember Lot s wife (Luke 17:31)! That is Jesus admonition for us. Lot s wife did herself in while running to
the place of safety in the plain of the Jordan after she had been delivered
from the destruction of Sodom. According
to Jesus she is the example we must not repeat.
There is no unconditional guarantee for our reaching the place of final
peace and rest after our deliverance from bondage to sin just as there was none
for her reaching the place of safety after her deliverance from the destruction
of Sodom.
We were saved
when we were delivered from bondage to sin, are being saved as we run the
course of salvation and will be saved when Jesus returns to bring us to eternal
life. We were regenerated, granted the
gift of faith, delivered from bondage to sin, placed in Christ, granted the
benefit of his atonement for our sins and justified and made righteous before
God when we provision mental assent to the good news of Jesus Christ that is
accompanied by repentance. We continue
to remain in Christ and continue to be justified and made righteous as we
continue to repent and continue to be willing to obey instructions in
scriptures. We shall be made righteous
for eternity to come when Jesus returns, roots up everything that causes sins
and bring us to eternal life. And so we will be with the Lord forever (1Thessalonians 4:17) , never to be
separated from him again. Until
then being justified and made righteous before God remains a process, the
outcome of which is non-deterministic from man s perspective with man himself
being the risk factor.
Ro 8:12
Therefore, brothers, we have an obligation but it is not to the sinful nature,
to live according to it.
Ro 8:13 For if you live according to the sinful nature, you will
die; but if by the Spirit you put to death the misdeeds of the body, you will
live,
Ro 8:14
because those who are led by the Spirit of God are sons of God.
Provisioning
repentance and willingness to obey instructions in scriptures for running the
course of salvation is not about man working for his salvation
When we repent and are
willing to obey instructions in scriptures, God will grant us the gift of faith
so that we can obey in deeds beyond mere willingness. As we continue to
repent and continue to be willing to obey, God will continue to grant us the
gift of faith so that we can continue to obey in deeds. We cannot possibly obey in deeds
without faith because faith is God s enablement for us to obey him in deeds
when we are willing. That is why
repentance and faith is the one and only cause for obedience in deeds, and obedience in deeds the one
and only indicator or proof of repentance and faith. God grants us the gift of faith today not
because we obey in deeds yesterday but because we are repentant and willing to
obey today. Being repentant and willing
to obey instructions in scriptures is an attitude; it has nothing to do with
work. There is therefore nothing at all
that we can do to cause God to grant us the gift of faith other than fomenting the
spirit of repentance and willingness to obey.
Please note that doing good deeds by itself does not prove
repentance and faith. It is obvious from
the fact that many who have not repented and who are not followers of Jesus
Christ are doing good deeds. But if a
person obeys instructions in scriptures to do good deeds, he has furnished
proof of his repentance and faith. The
emphasis must therefore be on obedience to instructions in scriptures and not
on the good deeds themselves for the proof of repentance and faith.
If we have doubt about the
claim that it is not our deeds but rather our obedience to instructions in
scriptures that furnishes proof of our repentance and faith, let s look at
James 2:21-26.
Jas
2:21 Was not our ancestor Abraham
considered righteous for what he did when he offered his son Isaac on the altar?
Jas 2:22 You see that his faith and his actions were working
together, and his faith was made complete by what he did.
Jas 2:23 And the scripture was fulfilled that says, Abraham believed
God, and it was credited to him as righteousness, and he was called God s
friend.
Jas 2:24 You see that a person is justified by what he does and not
by faith alone.
Jas 2:25 In
the same way, was not even Rahab the prostitute
considered righteous for what she did when she gave lodging to the spies and
sent them off in a different direction?
Jas 2:26 As the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without
deeds is dead.
When
we examine the story of Abraham sacrificing Isaac, we know that it was not a
righteous deed in itself. How righteous
was it for a man to kill his own son when his son had done nothing wrong? Or look at the story of Rahab
giving lodging to the Israelite spies and sending them off in a different
direction. How righteous was it for a
woman to betray her own people just to save herself and her own family? These deeds in themselves were barbaric and
treacherous; they did not stand on their own as being righteous at all. The only reason they could be considered righteous
was because they were done in obedience to God; that was what made them
righteous. Consequently when he referred
to a man being justified by what he did, James was referring to justification
by God-centric work that resulted from obedience to God and not by man-centric
work that resulted from man s own inclination for goodness. Only obedience to God could possibly justify
what Abraham and Rahab did. In fact we should never glamorize what they
did because what they did was barbaric and treacherous. We could only approve of their obedience to
God, not their savageness and treachery.
Therefore
any claim of repentance and faith is hollow when it leapfrogs obedience to
instructions in scriptures with fruit-bearing.
Obeying instructions in scriptures subsumes the sovereignty of God, the
Lordship of Jesus Christ and the transforming power of the Holy Spirit in the
life of a believer. If we think that we
can submit to the sovereignty of God, submit to the Lordship of Jesus Christ
and submit to the transforming power of the Holy Spirit without obeying
instructions in scriptures, we have short-circuited scriptures. The way we should emphasize God s sovereignty is not just insisting on
it intellectually or ramming it down other people s throat, but by the way we
live our own lives in obedience to instructions in scriptures. When a believer disobeys instructions in
scriptures, he rejects the sovereignty of God, the Lordship of Jesus Christ and
the transforming power of the Holy Spirit.
Jesus has given us instructions on what he expects of us in three
parables in Mathews Chapter 25 in regard to receiving salvation. When he returns, Jesus is not going to ask,
Tell me what you believe ; rather he is going to ask, Show me what you have
done in obedience to my commands . It is
in obeying his instructions on salvation and doing what he commands that we are
going to furnish the proof of our repentance and faith. When we obey
instructions in scriptures for running the course of salvation, we are not
working for our salvation because it is only the indicator of our preexisting repentance
and faith.
Furthermore when we try to gain salvation
with our self-conceived notion of justification by faith without obedience to
instructions in scriptures, we are coercing Jesus to grant us salvation the way
we mandate it, not the way he mandates it.
In essence we are demanding that Jesus have faith in our having faith in
him when we do not obey his instructions for running the course of salvation;
we are insisting that we be granted salvation since we can recite the magic
words justification by faith . The
biblical reality is that Jesus does not need to have faith in our having faith
in him; he only needs to see us bear fruit through obeying instructions in scriptures
as proof of our repentance and faith. We
need to stop romanticizing the idea of justification by faith without obedience
to instructions in scriptures for running the course of salvation it is not
biblical, hypocritical and ultimately fatal.
To those who rely on work for
their salvation God will have them rely on his grace. To those who indulge God s salvation grace
God will demand work from them. God is
more interested in fomenting in us a sense of balance and harmony rather than
molding us according to our pet ideology.
Please note that Paul emphasized faith because he was fending off those
who relied on their legalistic righteousness and that James emphasized work
because he was fending off those who indulged God s grace. We cannot simply use our personal experience
to force a mold on God because we have no harmony in our nature and do not have
the proper balance; we need both work and grace to strike a balance. We are self-centered and egotistic and always
speak from our own personal experience and ignore the experience of others as
though our personal experience were the entirety of spiritual reality. When we stop being self-centered and
egotistic, we would begin to strike a balance between faith and work.
On a more negative note, both Paul and
James had problems. Paul was eager to
push the envelope of the missionary enterprise and was in danger of turning
faith into mere mental assent. James had
a tendency to be legalistic and was in danger of turning faith into work. Paul and James failed to diffuse the tension
between them not because they did not recognize that the other side of the
argument was also valid but because they insisted on presenting a one-sided
view in order to cater to their own constituents among believers Gentiles for
Paul and Jews for James.
Jn 6:53 Jesus said to
them, I tell you the truth, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and
drink his blood, you have no life in you.
Jn 6:54 Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life,
and I will raise him up at the last day.
Jesus catered to no constituents and
would not hesitate to sieve his disciples who followed him for a humanistic
reason. As a result many of his
disciples left.
Jn 6:66 From this time many of his disciples turned back and no
longer followed him.
Paul should have sieved the Gentile
believers and told them in no uncertain terms what faith was instead of simply
dumping his theological statement of justification by faith on them without
ever deliberating on the definition of faith and leaving it totally up to them
to decide for themselves what faith was.
Had he done so, the missionary enterprise would not have seen as great
an expansion. In the same way James
should have sieved the Jewish believers and told them in no uncertain terms
what faith was in relation to work instead of simply getting by and letting them
drive its definition in accordance with their Jewish tradition. Had he done so, the church in Jerusalem would
not have seen as great an expansion.
Unfortunately for Paul and James they chose
to cater to their constituents instead of sieving them the way Jesus would his
disciples. Those who come after them
would find it natural to do the same and indeed they have been doing it. Each should have presented a harmonized view of
faith and work. That would have brought
about the best outcome for the household of God within their generation. They had missed their opportunity. Not only that but they had set a bad example
among believers through the generations for their failure to harmonize. Believers find it justifiable to be divisive
and contentious and to pay no attention to harmonization even when scriptural
evidence demands it. We should recognize
where some of the apostles had fallen short and stop idolizing them as though
they were flawless.
Scriptures present both sides of the
argument not because we are supposed to pick one over the other in accordance
with our own preference. We are supposed
to strike a balance and come to a harmonized understanding of both sides
instead. We are to have harmony in our
own nature and cause no undue tension among believers. If we fail to harmonize and fail to diffuse
the tension, it is a testimony that we have failed the same way Paul and James
did. They will be held accountable for
their failure to harmonize and the bad precedent they had set for generations of
believers that come after them. So shall
we be if we perpetuate their mistake.
When we repent and are willing to obey,
God will grant us the gift of faith and will guide us into the truth of
scriptures and we would have the right theology. When we emphasize theology without repentance
and the resultant obedience to instructions in scriptures, we will lose grip of
theology and we will introduce all sorts of falsehood into our belief because
God stops granting us the gift of faith.
Emphasizing theology without repentance and the resultant obedience is a
losing proposition. With repentance and
the resultant obedience to instructions in scriptures we will have a heart that
is receptive to the truth and a heart that loves the truth, and we will have
our theology straight. Why do we think
that we by ourselves can hold on to the truth?
No, our holding on to the truth must be sustained by God. Start emphasizing repentance and the
resultant willingness to obey instructions in scriptures and God will see to it
that we will hold on to the right theology by granting us the gift of faith.
The deeper the
repentance a person undergoes, the greater the willingness to obey instructions
in scriptures he exhibits and the greater the faith he is granted. Peter repented much from his disowning
Jesus three times. Paul repented much
from his persecuting followers of Jesus.
Abraham repented much from his impatience for a son when Isaac was born. Moses repented much when he decided to turn
away from the pleasures of Egypt and refused to be counted among those who
oppressed his people. Out of deep
repentance came faith and obedience in deeds that was manifest in the lives of
these people. On the other hand the
Pharisees were self-righteous and did not see any need for repentance. Their lack of repentance explained their lack
of faith and disobedience to the good news.
There is a direct correlation between repentance, willingness to obey,
faith and obedience in deeds. It explains why Paul declared that he had kept the faith
in 2 Timothy 4:7. No one otherwise would
be in a position to declare that he has done so.
Deliverance
from the ultimate destruction of sin at the end of the age and obedience in
deeds throughout life are the peer end effects of the causal chain of salvation
as a lifelong process
As
has been discussed, salvation is not cast in concrete through the onetime event
of deliverance from bondage to sin.
God s implementation plan of salvation is not for a onetime event but for
a process that spans the entire lifetime of man. Fulfillment of the causal chain of
deliverance from bondage to sin inaugurates salvation as a lifelong
process. Deliverance from the ultimate
destruction of sin - hell - is contingent upon man s continual provision of repentance
and willingness to obey instructions in scriptures throughout that process,
whereupon the Holy Spirit will continue to grant him the gift of faith so that
he can continue to obey in deeds. It is
when he persists in the provision of repentance and willingness to obey to the
very end of his life that a person will be delivered from the ultimate
destruction when Jesus returns. If he
refuses to do so, the Holy Spirit will not continue to grant him the gift of
faith and he will shipwreck his faith.
The causal chain of salvation as a lifelong
process branches in two separate terminations as peer end effects. On the one hand it terminates in deliverance
from the ultimate destruction of sin at the end of the age as an end effect; on
the other it continually terminates in obedience in deeds throughout life as a
separate peer end effect, which serves as proof of repentance and faith for the
coming judgment. Please also note that
obedience in deeds is not a cause on the causal chain of salvation as a
lifelong process that leads to deliverance from the ultimate destruction of sin
at the end of the age; it is only an end effect of the causal chain as
deliverance is. Therefore man does not
contribute to the causal chain of salvation as a lifelong process through
obedience in deeds, i.e., does not work for his salvation. Rather he makes contribution through
repentance and willingness to obey instructions in scriptures, which is an
attitude and has nothing to do with work.
Obedience in deeds does not lead to a person s deliverance from the
ultimate destruction of sin at the end of the age but is rather the inevitable
and observable behavior pattern of a repentant person who exercises his faith
post deliverance from bondage to sin.
Therefore the
causal chain of salvation as a lifelong process provides clear indication that
man can have no way of working for his salvation. As we continue to repent and to be willing to
obey instructions in scriptures, the Holy Spirit will continue to grant us the
gift of faith. With a continuous supply
of faith we will continue to exhibit obedience in deeds in accordance with
instructions in scriptures. And we
depend on the Holy Spirit moment by moment for an uninterrupted supply of faith
in order to persevere in our obedience. The
Holy Spirit continues to grant us the gift of faith today, not because we
exhibited obedience in deeds yesterday but because we continue to repent and to
be willing to obey today. The gift of
faith is granted anew one day at a time, moment by moment when we are willing
to obey instructions in scriptures and not because we have been able to obey. In other words we are granted the gift of
faith for our repentant spirit and willingness to obey and not because we have
earned it by our obedience in deeds. The
continual granting of the gift of faith by the Holy Spirit upon our continual
repentance and willingness to obey enables us to continue to bear fruit, which
is our obedience in deeds and the proof of our repentance and faith for the
coming judgment.
Issue #4: Would God unilaterally
impose his grace of salvation on a person such that the person would have no
way of resisting it?
In regard to issue #4 we are
going to validate from scriptures that God does not grant
repentance only to some but the privilege of repentance to all and on rare occasions special enablement for repentance.
God does not grant repentance only to some but instead the
privilege of repentance to all and on rare occasions
special enablement for repentance
Some of us who hold extreme views of salvation would quote the
following verse of scriptures and claim that God must grant repentance through
regeneration by the Holy Spirit before a person can repent.
Ac 5:31 God
exalted him to his own right hand as Prince and Savior that he might give repentance
and forgiveness of sins to Israel.
God granting
repentance and forgiveness of sin to Israel does not mean that all Israel would
repent and receive forgiveness of sin without exception because not all Israel
repents and receives forgiveness of sin.
The proper interpretation must account for this reality. The interpretation can be that God has made
it possible for Israel to be saved through repentance and forgiveness of sin
that was previously not possible. Some would take
advantage of the privilege of repentance and be saved while others would
not. This interpretation of the passage would account for the reality that
not all Israel repents and receives forgiveness of sin.
Those who hold
extreme views of salvation would say that God grants repentance only to some
but not all of the Israelites and that those who have been granted repentance
would repent without exception. It is
possible to interpret the verse that way.
But the interpretation is less consistent with the context than the
other interpretation because it is assuming that Israel does not mean all
Israel and that those granted the repentance would accept it without exception
while the other interpretation only assumes that those granted the privilege of
repentance could choose not to act on it. An interpretation is better if it makes fewer
assumptions. If we want to introduce the
notion of universal acceptance of repentance by those who have been granted the
repentance that is not stated in this context in order to support the interpretation,
it is again a weaker interpretation because the other interpretation does not
rely on things outside of this context.
If the introduced notion has the support of unequivocal evidence in
scriptures, that would be another story.
But the reality is that it has been shown earlier that man can refuse to
repent even with Jesus enablement for repentance by way of miracles.
The argumentation
above accomplishes nothing in reality and is futile because it could go on and
on forever just as it has gone on for centuries. It only serves to illustrate the presence of
shades of grey suggesting that there is no conclusive evidence in this verse of
scriptures for the purpose of identifying the role of God and man in man s
repentance. Other passages of scriptures
such as the following should instead be examined for that purpose.
Ac 2:37 When the people
heard this, they were cut to the heart and said to Peter and the other
apostles, Brothers, what shall we do?
Ac 2:38
Peter replied, Repent and be baptized, every
one of you, in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins. And
you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.
Verse 38 shows that
repentance chronologically precedes regeneration by the Holy Spirit. It is sufficient to refute the claim that God must grant repentance through
regeneration by the Holy Spirit before a person can repent. Rather man can choose to repent and that
leads to regeneration instead of the other way round. In other words God does not grant repentance
but the privilege of repentance such that those who are willing to repent can
choose to.
Jewish believers
at first thought that only Israel but not the Gentiles had been granted the
privilege of repentance and salvation.
Then they realized that God had also granted the Gentiles the privilege as
seen through Peter s encounter with Cornelius and those in his house.
Ac 11:18 When they heard this, they
had no further objections and praised God, saying, So then, God has granted
even the Gentiles repentance unto life.
God granting the
Gentiles repentance unto life does not mean that all the Gentiles would repent
and receive eternal life without exception because not all the Gentiles repent. The proper interpretation must account for
this reality. The interpretation can be
that God has made it possible for the Gentiles to be saved through repentance
that was previously not possible. Some would take
advantage of the privilege of repentance and be saved while others would
not. This interpretation of the passage would account for the reality
that not all the Gentiles repent and receive eternal life.
1Ti 4:9 This is a trustworthy saying that deserves full
acceptance
1Ti 4:10 (and for this we labor and
strive), that we have put our hope in the living God, who is the Savior of all
men, and especially of those who believe.
Verse 10 provides
conclusive evidence that God is the Savior of all men and not just of those who
believe. For that reason God must also
grant the privilege of repentance to all men instead of granting repentance to
some but not the others so that whosoever among all men is willing to repent
would receive salvation - the benefit of God being his savior. The rest of all men who refuse to repent
would not receive salvation and therefore forfeit the benefit of God being
their savior. If he grants repentance to
some but not the others, God cannot be the Savior of all men but only those he grants
repentance to.
Jn 12:30 Jesus said,
This voice was for your benefit, not mine.
Jn 12:31 Now is the time
for judgment on this world; now the prince of this world will be driven
out.
Jn 12:32 But I, when I am
lifted up from the earth, will draw all men to myself.
Jn
12:33 He said this to show the kind of death he was going to
die.
Since all men indeed mean all men and not
all men repent and obey the good news of Jesus Christ even
though Jesus draws all
men to himself, all men must have been granted the privilege of repentance and
hence an independent choice in the matter of repentance. Please note that it is not a simple matter of
man choosing to repent and obey the good news of Jesus Christ on his own;
rather Jesus has to enable man and grant him the privilege of repentance first. And Jesus has done so for all men by drawing
them to himself when he was nailed to the cross. Some would take advantage of the privilege of
repentance and be saved while others would not.
If Jesus grants repentance to some but not the others such that those
who have been granted repentance would repent without exception, why would he
draw all men to himself? Granting the
privilege of repentance to all men is therefore a more consistent
interpretation of God s role in man s repentance in comparison to granting
repentance only to some but not the others.
The following passages of scriptures
similarly refer to Jesus dying for all men, not just for some but also the
others, in order to be the atoning sacrifice for the sins of all men and to be the
ransom for all men.
2Co 5:14 For Christ s
love compels us, because we are convinced that one died for all, and therefore
all died.
2Co 5:15 And
he died for all, that those who live should no longer live for themselves but
for him who died for them and was raised again.
Heb 2:9 But we see Jesus, who was
made a little lower than the angels, now crowned with glory and honor because
he suffered death, so that by the grace of God he might taste death for
everyone.
1Ti 2:3 This is good, and pleases God our Savior,
1Ti 2:4 who wants all
men to be saved and to come to a knowledge of the truth.
1Ti 2:5 For there is one God and one mediator between God and men,
the man Christ Jesus,
1Ti 2:6 who gave himself as a ransom for all men the testimony
given in its proper time.
1Jn 2:1 My dear children, I write this to you so that you will not sin.
But if anybody does sin, we have one who speaks to the Father in our
defense Jesus Christ, the Righteous One.
1Jn 2:2 He is the atoning sacrifice
for our sins, and not only for ours but also for the sins of the whole world.
The above passages of scriptures again lead to the conclusion that Jesus must grant the privilege of
repentance to all men instead of granting repentance to some but not the
others.
2Ti 2:24 And the Lord s servant must not quarrel; instead, he must be
kind to everyone, able to teach, not resentful.
2Ti 2:25 Those who oppose him he must gently instruct, in the hope
that God will grant them repentance leading them to a knowledge of the
truth,
2Ti 2:26 and
that they will come to their senses and escape from the trap of the devil, who
has taken them captive to do his will.
Please note that
the granting of repentance in this context is in regard to those who are
opposed to the truth. But if God has
already granted both Jews and Gentiles the privilege of repentance as discussed
earlier, why is there a need for God to again grant it to those who oppose the
truth? We are going to explore the
reality behind that next.
In this passage
of scriptures Paul provided Timothy with the instruction for dealing with
people who are opposed to the truth.
Please note that it was a generalization because it did not refer to a
specific example of people who oppose the truth with a known outcome in regard
to repentance. The prognosis for
repentance for those who oppose the truth is rather uncertain in this
context. That was why Paul was vague
about what would happen in that type of situation. It is unwise to draw a quick conclusion about
the mechanics of repentance based on such generalization and vagueness of outcome. We need to examine specific examples in
similar situations in scriptures in order to come to a more in-depth
understanding of the mechanics of repentance in context for people who oppose
the truth.
Please note that both
Jews and Gentiles have already been granted the privilege of repentance. Anyone who is willing to repent can, but a
person who is opposed to the truth can no longer repent of his own accord because
he has forfeited the privilege by his opposition. The only way for God to make repentance
possible for him is for God to provide special enablement for repentance. Pharaoh, Saul (Paul), the Jewish religious
leaders were examples.
Pharaoh s
conflict of interest with the truth was so strong and so much was at stake for
him that he would not have relented and kept renewing his promise to let the
Israelites go unless God brought on a new plague every time he broke his
promise. Each plague was a fresh special
enablement from God for Pharaoh to repent.
That was how Pharaoh kept renewing his promise after he had broken it. But God did not provide special enablement
for repentance indefinitely when Pharaoh kept breaking his promise. Pharaoh reached the point of no return and
drowned in the Red Sea when God took away any further opportunity for
repentance because of his unrelenting opposition to the truth.
Pharaoh s example
shows that even when God provides special enablement for repentance on a
repeated basis, there is no guarantee that a person would truly repent if the
person has conflict of interest with the truth.
It also shows that if a person is in constant opposition to the truth,
he is in grave danger of reaching the point of no return. The Jewish religious leaders were another such
example.
Jn 11:43 When he had said
this, Jesus called in a loud voice, Lazarus, come out!
Jn 11:44 The dead man came out, his hands and feet wrapped with
strips of linen, and a cloth around his face. Jesus said to them, Take off the
grave clothes and let him go.
Jn 11:45 Therefore many
of the Jews who had come to visit Mary, and had seen what Jesus did, put their
faith in him.
Jn 11:46 But some of them
went to the Pharisees and told them what Jesus had done.
Jn 11:47 Then the chief
priests and the Pharisees called a meeting of the Sanhedrin. What are we
accomplishing? they asked. Here is this man performing many miraculous
signs.
Jn 11:48 If we let him go on like this, everyone will believe in him,
and then the Romans will come and take away both our place and our nation.
Jn 11:49 Then one of
them, named Caiaphas, who was high priest that year,
spoke up, You know nothing at all!
Jn
11:50 You do not realize that it is
better for you that one man die for the people than that the whole nation
perish.
Jn
11:51 He did not say this on his own, but as high priest that
year he prophesied that Jesus would die for the Jewish nation,
Jn
11:52 and not only for that nation but also for the scattered
children of God, to bring them together and make them one.
Jn
11:53 So from that day on they plotted
to take his life.
Verse 45 says that many of
the Jews put their faith in Jesus upon witnessing the miracle Jesus did in
raising Lazarus from the dead. (Please
note that putting their faith in Jesus should be translated as believing in
Jesus instead for lack of evidence of obedience in deeds in the context.) But the Jewish religious leaders plotted to
take Jesus life because of the miracle.
For the same miracle some people chose to believe while others refused
to. The miracle was special enablement
from God for all who witnessed it to repent but the Jewish religious leaders
chose to plot his death instead because they had conflict of interest with the
truth as made clear in verse 48. They
had seen on separate occasions the blind receive their sight, the cripple walk
and the dead raised and yet refused to obey the truth. Like Pharaoh they were in grave danger of
reaching the point of no return because of their unyielding opposition to the
truth.
Lk 5:4 When he had finished speaking, he said to Simon, Put out
into deep water, and let down the nets for a catch.
Lk 5:5 Simon answered,
Master, we ve worked hard all night and haven t caught anything. But because
you say so, I will let down the nets.
Lk 5:6 When they had
done so, they caught such a large number of fish that their nets began to
break.
Lk 5:7 So they signaled their partners in the other boat to come
and help them, and they came and filled both boats so full that they began to
sink.
Lk 5:8 When Simon Peter
saw this, he fell at Jesus knees and said, Go away
from me, Lord; I am a sinful man!
What Peter experienced was
nothing compared to seeing Lazarus being raised from the dead. It shows that some would repent with lesser
special enablement from God while others would not repent even with greater special
enablement. It again shows that
different people have different inclination for repentance and that man plays a
part in his repentance independent of God s enablement.
Jn 12:37 Even after Jesus
had done all these miraculous signs in their presence, they still would not
believe in him.
Jn 12:38 This was to
fulfill the word of Isaiah the prophet: Lord, who has believed our message and
to whom has the arm of the Lord been revealed?
Jn 12:39 For this reason
they could not believe, because, as Isaiah says elsewhere:
Jn 12:40 He has blinded
their eyes and deadened their hearts, so they can
neither see with their eyes, nor understand with their hearts, nor turn and I
would heal them.
Jn
12:41 Isaiah said this because he saw Jesus glory and spoke
about him.
Jn
12:42 Yet at the same time many even
among the leaders believed in him. But because of the Pharisees they would not
confess their faith for fear they would be put out of the synagogue;
Jn
12:43 for they loved praise from men more than praise from God.
Jesus miracles were special enablement
for repentance. Even with the special
enablement the Jews did not repent. On
the other hand there were those who did repent upon witnessing the miraculous
signs. This again shows that different
people have different inclination for repentance and that man plays a part in
his repentance that is independent of God s enablement. When some refuse to repent even with God s
special enablement because of conflict of interest with the truth, God blinds
their eyes and deadens their hearts so that they would have no possibility of repenting
thus effectively taking away their privilege of repentance - they have reached
the point of no return - as prophesied by Isaiah.
Please note that there are different levels
of conflict of interest with the truth.
The Pharisees would not believe in Jesus even with God s special enablement
because their conflict of interest with the truth was irreconcilable. For others who would not confess their belief
for fear of being put out of the synagogue, they believed secretly. It was a lesser conflict of interest with the
truth such that God did not take away their privilege of repentance and
therefore they could still repent, though it was compromised to a certain
extent.
This is in contrast to Saul (Paul)
who upon God s special enablement for repentance on the road to Damascus repented
without reservation because he did not have conflict of interest with the truth
even though he persecuted followers of Jesus.
He persecuted them out
of ignorance and not out of conflict of interest.
1Ti 1:13 Even though I (Paul)
was once a blasphemer and a persecutor and a violent man, I was shown mercy because I acted in ignorance and unbelief.
1Ti 1:14 The
grace of our Lord was poured out on me abundantly, along with the faith and
love that are in Christ Jesus.
Scriptures did
not depict Paul in association with any conflict of interest with the truth in
his persecution of the church. He
persecuted the church because he thought he was doing God s will - he opposed
the truth out of ignorance. Upon God s
special enablement for repentance he repented.
Only God s special enablement for repentance could turn Paul from the
error of his way because he opposed the truth and had forfeited the privilege
of repentance. The moment spiritual
reality was torn wide open before him on the road to Damascus, he immediately
embraced the truth and started preaching that Jesus was the Christ with as much
zeal as he had opposed it. There was no
conflict of interest that held him captive to disobedience. It shows that he was the type of person who
would do with great zeal what he thought was God s will, whatever it was. It was not out of conflict of interest that
he opposed the truth.
Please note that
God s special enablement for repentance does not come in such a way as to
neutralize a person s conflict of interest with the truth, but in such a way as
to tear spiritual reality wide open. The
person has to be honest with himself and to make a
decision as to whether he would submit to God who has been encountered. That is the purpose of God providing special
enablement for repentance. It is not
about compelling a person to repent such that he has no way not to, but about
making it clear to the person that he needs to repent and to submit to God
because God has made himself known.
Pharaoh and the Jewish religious leaders chose to protect their
self-interest and so continued to refuse to repent.
The examples of
Pharaoh, the Jewish religious leaders and Paul show that anyone who opposes the
truth needs special enablement from God for repentance. If he harbors conflict of interest with the
truth, he will not repent even with God s special enablement. If he harbors no conflict of interest with
the truth, he will. But it is not
certain that God would provide special enablement for repentance for everyone
who does not repent. In the case of the
people of Tyre, Sidon and Sodom that Jesus made a
comparison with the people of Korazin, Bethsaida and
Capernaum, no special enablement for repentance was provided even though they
would have repented, had God provided it.
The provision of special enablement from God for repentance is
completely uncertain.
That is why in
his instruction to Timothy Paul used a rather uncertain tone in hoping that God
would grant repentance to those who were opposed to the truth. There is also the possibility that the person
would not repent even when God provides special enablement for repentance, if
he harbors conflict of interest with the truth.
Hoping for others to repent through God s intervention in this context
is no more certain than hoping for a revival of the church from God.
In a revival of
the church God provides special enablement for repentance by tearing spiritual reality
wide open. Many would repent but there
are also those who refuse to, presumably because of conflict of interest with
the truth. People can still choose to
ignore spiritual reality because there may not be immediate consequence in so
doing. Furthermore some people would
choose to ignore it even when there is immediate consequence as in the case of
Pharaoh. The conflict of interest with
the truth was so strong and so much was at stake for Pharaoh that it overrode
even the immediate consequence of ignoring spiritual reality. But when Jesus returns, the consequence of
ignoring spiritual reality can no longer be suppressed because its punishment
would be meted out and there will be no further delay. That is when all who have not repented can no
longer ignore their plight. They will
want to repent but will be rejected.
Lk 13:24 Make every
effort to enter through the narrow door, because many, I tell you, will try to
enter and will not be able to.
Lk 13:25 Once the owner
of the house gets up and closes the door, you will stand outside knocking and
pleading, Sir, open the door for us.
But he will answer, I don t know you or
where you come from.
Lk 13:26 Then you will
say, We ate and drank with you, and you taught in our streets.
Lk 13:27 But he will
reply, I don t know you or where you come from. Away from
me, all you evildoers!
When we ask for a revival of
the church, we are asking for God s special enablement for repentance for the
church. Please note that requests for
God s special enablement for repentance are consistently rejected in scriptures
because those who ask for it could repent if they so choose. It is regarded as hypocrisy on man s part and
a matter of pushing man s responsibility for repentance on God. You see, we can enter into a personal
spiritual renewal where we renew our obedience to instructions in scriptures
for running the course of salvation right at this moment if we choose to repent
without the need for God s special enablement.
When we ask for a revival of the church, we must have voluntarily
entered into a personal spiritual renewal ourselves. Otherwise we would be found to be
hypocritical.
It is important
to note that God granting special enablement for repentance has something to do
with the attitude of those who are hoping for it. Paul s exhortation for Timothy as the Lord s
servant to not argue and to gently instruct in hope that God would grant the
special enablement bears that out. In
fact Paul s exhortation implied that if the Lord s servant argued and did not
gently instruct, there was no possibility that God would grant the special
enablement. That being the case, those
of us who are hoping for a revival of the church should mind their attitude
because it can be a determining factor.
God unilaterally
granting repentance apart from man s independent choice is an extreme position
because it would need to completely refute all evidence in scriptures that
suggests man s participation in such a capacity. By nature an extreme position cannot accommodate
any opposing evidence and permits no shade of gray in scriptures. Any evidence to the contrary and any shade of
gray would cast doubt on its validity.
When a passage of scriptures cannot be interpreted literally because of
vagueness inherent in language and vagueness of description, it opens up
various possibilities for interpretation and allows for shades of grey. This sort of fussiness weakens arguments for
extreme positions and strengthens arguments for moderation from them.
Issue #5: Why do some receive
salvation when Jesus returns while others do not?
In regard to issue #5 we are
going to examine the following in scriptures:
Scriptures do not provide a concrete
specific reason why some people have the opportunity to hear the good news of Jesus
Christ while others do not.
Why do some people who hear the good news
of Jesus Christ have faith while others do not?
Why and when would God provide special
enablement for repentance?
Is God more gracious in providing special
enablement for repentance?
Not all who are
delivered from bondage to sin will receive salvation.
Scriptures do not provide a concrete specific reason why
some people have the opportunity to hear the good news of Jesus Christ while
others do not
Having the opportunity to
hear the good news of Jesus Christ is the precondition for salvation. Scriptures do not provide a concrete specific
reason why some people have the opportunity to hear the good news and hence the
opportunity to repent and to be saved while others do
not. The answer to this question cannot
be readily ascertained from scriptures. Scriptures
are generally more concerned with the necessity for those who hear the good
news to repent and obey.
Why do some people who hear the good news of Jesus Christ have
faith while others do not?
The conclusion has been
reached earlier in this sub-study that repentance is the gateway to salvation
and that repentance is man s responsibility while granting repentant man the
gift of faith is God s. Man can choose
to repent or refuse to repent after he has heard the good news. When he provisions mental assent to the good
news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by repentance, the Holy Spirit
regenerates him, grants him the gift of faith and delivers him from bondage to
sin, which sets him on running the course of salvation. For those who refuse to repent, God sometimes
provides special enablement for repentance.
If they do not harbor conflict of interest with the truth, they will
repent with God s special enablement for repentance. If they harbor conflict of interest, they will
not repent even with God s special enablement.
Why and when would God provide special enablement for
repentance?
In providing special
enablement for repentance God tears open spiritual reality and confronts man
with the wide-open spiritual reality for him to see his need for
repentance. Some who are not under normal
circumstances inclined to repent would; others who are not under normal
circumstances inclined to repent would continue to refuse to repent. Please note that God providing special
enablement for repentance happens very rarely.
Providing it is entirely God s sovereign choice. There is no prediction when or under what
circumstance God would do it.
Let s review the following
passage of scriptures that has been examined earlier.
Mt 11:20 Then
Jesus began to denounce the cities in which most of his miracles had been
performed, because they did not repent.
Mt 11:21 Woe to you, Korazin! Woe to you, Bethsaida! If the miracles
that were performed in you had been performed in Tyre
and Sidon, they would have repented long ago in sackcloth and ashes.
Mt 11:22 But I tell you,
it will be more bearable for Tyre and Sidon on the day of judgment than for you.
Mt 11:23 And you, Capernaum, will you be lifted up to the skies? No,
you will go down to the depths. If the miracles that were performed in you had
been performed in Sodom, it would have remained to this day.
Mt 11:24 But I tell you
that it will be more bearable for Sodom on the day of
judgment than for you.
Jesus knows all things such that he knew that people in Tyre, Sidon and Sodom would have repented, had the miracles
he performed in Korazin, Bethsaida and Capernaum been
performed in those cities. That was the level of inclination for repentance
for the people of Tyre,
Sidon and Sodom. The people of Korazin, Bethsaida and Capernaum did not repent even with
God s special enablement for repentance.
That was their level of inclination for repentance.
Since the people of Tyre, Sidon and Sodom in actuality were not provided with special
enablement for repentance, they did not repent.
It might suggest that man can repent if he so chooses and if he does
not, it is enough ground for condemnation and that was why God did not provide
the people of Tyre, Sidon and Sodom with special
enablement for repentance. They will be
judged according to their level of inclination for repentance at the judgment. On the other hand God did provide the people
of Korazin, Bethsaida and Capernaum with special enablement
for repentance and they did not repent.
The special enablement might serve as a means to plough the depth of
their vehement refusal to repent and they will be judged according to their
level of inclination for repentance at the judgment.
What a shock it will be to
the people of Korazin, Bethsaida and Capernaum that
they would come out short in comparison to the people of Tyre,
Sidon, and yes, Sodom! It is not
necessarily evildoing that incurs the greatest judgment but refusal to repent
when God has provided the special enablement for repentance. Jesus did not condemn the people of Korazin, Bethsaida and Capernaum for their inability to
repent; he condemned them for their refusal to repent when they had been
provided the special enablement for repentance.
They had no excuse not to repent with God s special enablement since the
people of Tyre, Sidon and Sodom would have repented,
had they been given the same special enablement.
Is God more gracious in providing special enablement for
repentance?
Special enablement for
repentance is grace from God when a person repents and a curse from God when he
does not because he would be judged more severely. God did not appear to be more gracious to the
people of Korazin, Bethsaida and Capernaum than to
the people of Tyre, Sidon and Sodom in the matter of
special enablement for repentance because the former would be punished more
severely for non-repentance. In other
words God s special enablement for repentance is a double-edge sword.
But was God more gracious to
Paul than to the people of Tyre, Sidon and Sodom in
the matter of special enablement for repentance? On the surface the answer might appear to be
affirmative because had the people of Tyre, Sidon and
Sodom been provided with special enablement, they would have repented. On the surface it might appear that God shows
favoritism to those whom he provides with special enablement for repentance and
who would not have otherwise repented, but not to those whom he does not and
who would have otherwise repented.
As has already been discussed, Paul persecuted the church because
he thought he was doing God a service and not because he had any conflict of
interest with the truth. God would
provide special enablement for repentance for a person like Paul, zealous for
doing God s will but going about it in a wrong way out of ignorance. As for the people of Tyre,
Sidon and Sodom, they might be so bent on doing evil, especially the people of
Sodom, that God had no consideration for them in terms of providing special
enablement for repentance. Perhaps God has
a preference in providing people like Paul with special enablement for
repentance. But that preference is not
the same as favoritism because favoritism would be a legitimate complaint when preference is shown to
one over the other when both parties are considered equal. But Paul and the people of Tyre,
Sidon and Sodom appeared to belong in different categories.
The Philippian jailer is yet another example of God providing
special enablement for repentance in the form of a miracle. Without the special enablement the jailer
would not have repented. On the other
hand the miracle itself could not have been the sole cause of his repentance
because his first reaction to the prison doors flying open and everybody s chains coming loose was to kill himself. It was when Paul and Silas chose not to flee
in order to spare his life that he no longer wanted to kill himself but asked
what he must do to be saved. In other
words the miracle, absent the modulation by the attitude of Paul and Silas,
could not have served as enablement for repentance for the jailer. It would have been a curse for the jailer instead,
had Paul and Silas fled. It is not easy
to answer the question whether the miracle by itself was God s favor to the
jailer or whether God favored the jailer over the people of Tyre,
Sidon and Sodom because not much is known about the jailer.
What about those
who repent in a revival of the church? Does
God favor them? If those who would
repent in a revival and would not without one encounter a revival, God appears
to favor them over those who would repent in a revival and would not without
one and who does not encounter a revival.
But then how would we know that the former would not repent without a
revival if they have repented in one?
Or how would we know that the latter would repent in a revival if they
never encounter one? Because we are not
all-knowing, we are not in a position to answer the question whether God favors
those who repent in a revival of the church.
From
what has been discussed, it is not certain whether God shows favoritism when it
comes to providing special enablement for repentance. But doesn t the bible say that God does not
show favoritism in the context of salvation?
Let s examine that passage of scriptures in the Book of Acts.
Ac 10:34 Then Peter began
to speak: I now realize how true it is that God does not show favoritism
Ac 10:35 but
accepts men from every nation who fear him and do what is right.
Peter made the
above remark when he found out the reason Cornelius invited him to Cornelius
home. He came to the realization that
God made no difference between Jews and Gentiles when it came to salvation, but
accepted men from every nation who feared him and did what was right.
Please note that
God not showing favoritism is in the context of granting the gift of faith when
a person is willing to repent. It does
not matter whether a person is a Jew or a Gentile, as long as he repents, he
will be granted the gift of faith. God
shows favoritism if two people repent but God grants one the gift of faith but
not the other. Please note that Peter
described Cornelius in verse 35 as fearing God and doing what was right. Cornelius was duly granted the gift of faith
when he demonstrated the spirit of repentance and the resultant spirit of
obedience, even though he was a Gentile.
He demonstrated the spirit of repentance and the resultant spirit of
obedience as seen in the following passage of scriptures before Peter was
invited to his home.
Ac 10:1 At
Caesarea there was a man named Cornelius, a centurion in what was known as the
Italian Regiment.
Ac 10:2 He
and all his family were devout and God-fearing; he gave generously to those in
need and prayed to God regularly.
Ac 10:3 One
day at about three in the afternoon he had a vision. He distinctly saw an angel
of God, who came to him and said, Cornelius!
Ac 10:4
Cornelius stared at him in fear. What is it, Lord? he asked. The angel
answered, Your prayers and gifts to the poor have come up as a memorial
offering before God.
Ac 10:5 Now send men to Joppa to bring back a man named Simon who is
called Peter.
Ac 10:6 He is staying with Simon the
tanner, whose house is by the sea.
As Peter entered
into Cornelius home and delivered the good news of Jesus Christ, the Holy
Spirit came on all who heard the message.
Then they were baptized in the name of Jesus.
Ac 10:44
While Peter was still speaking these words, the Holy Spirit came on all who
heard the message.
Ac 10:45 The circumcised believers who had come with Peter were
astonished that the gift of the Holy Spirit had been poured out even on the
Gentiles.
Ac 10:46 For they heard them speaking in tongues and praising God.
Then Peter said,
Ac 10:47 Can
anyone keep these people from being baptized with water? They have received the
Holy Spirit just as we have.
Ac 10:48 So
he ordered that they be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ. Then they asked
Peter to stay with them for a few days.
It was because Cornelius
had demonstrated the spirit of repentance and the resultant spirit of obedience
in the way he conducted himself that God granted him and his household the gift
of the Holy Spirit. God does not show
favoritism in the sense that when a person, whether a Jew or a Gentile,
demonstrates a repentant spirit, God would grant him the gift of the Holy
Spirit and the gift of faith without exception.
This is different from the matter of God providing special enablement
for repentance in that it is unpredictable when and under what circumstance God
would provide the special enablement.
Perhaps it appears unpredictable simply because of our own ignorance. So God does not show favoritism when it comes
to granting the gift of faith the moment a person repents. But it is not certain for lack of information
in scriptures whether God shows favoritism when it comes to providing special
enablement for repentance.
Not all who are delivered from bondage to sin will
receive salvation
Heb 9:28 so Christ was sacrificed
once to take away the sins of many people; and he will appear a second time,
not to bear sin, but to bring salvation to those who are waiting for him.
According to this verse of
scriptures the first time Jesus came, it was for delivering many people from bondage
to sin. The second time he comes, it
will be for bringing salvation to those who are waiting for him. Please note that it does not say that
salvation will be given to those whose sins have been taken away the first time
he came; rather it says that salvation will be given to those who are waiting
for him. The mechanics of salvation
discussed in the current sub-study correlates with this verse of scriptures. If we have been delivered from bondage to sin
but do not wait for his return, we will shipwreck our faith and will not
receive salvation when Jesus returns. Thus
Jesus puts the responsibility for how we run the course of salvation in order
to receive salvation squarely on those whom he has delivered.
Mt 7:13 Enter through
the narrow gate. For wide is the gate and broad is the road that leads to
destruction, and many enter through it.
Mt 7:14 But small is the gate and narrow the
road that leads to life, and only a few find it.
Though according to Hebrews
9:28 he took away the sins of many people the first time he came, Jesus would
grant salvation to only the few who enter through the narrow gate and take the
narrow road while running the course of salvation. Just because he has delivered us from bondage
to sin, it is not our inevitable destiny that we shall receive salvation when
Jesus returns; having delivered us from bondage to sin does not oblige Jesus to
grant us salvation at all. It is only
the few who enter through the narrow gate and take the narrow road post
deliverance who will receive salvation.
When it comes to salvation,
we may be fixated on the idea of being born again and make the assumption that
the moment we are born again, we are destined to
receive salvation when Jesus returns. As
has been discussed earlier in this sub-study, we will shipwreck our faith if we
refuse to continue to repent and to be wiling to obey instructions in
scriptures for running the course of salvation post deliverance from bondage to
sin by the Holy Spirit. God would not in
his sovereign power force us to comply just as he did not force Lot s wife to
comply with the angels instruction not to look back, nor did he force the
Israelites to comply with his command to enter Canaan. Being willing to obey instructions in
scriptures for running the course of salvation is a personal choice each
believer has to make in order to receive salvation when Jesus returns.
Finally it is by God s grace
that we have been set on running the course of salvation. Being willing to obey instructions in
scriptures for running the course of salvation is how we stay in God s salvation
grace. On the other hand we would not
receive salvation until Jesus returns.
There is no such a thing as losing our salvation because we have not
received our salvation to begin with, only deliverance from bondage to sin. The next sub-study will deal particularly
with the issue of the security of a believer in the context of salvation.
Conclusion
The current sub-study has
laid out the interaction between man and God in the context of man s salvation
as a life-long process initiated by a onetime event of deliverance from bondage
to sin. It demonstrates the presence of
shades of grey in the continuum between God s enablement and man s independent
choice throughout that process. It
testifies to the necessity for the doctrine of salvation to be based on a
middle position.
Such a view of the doctrine
of salvation is consistent with the consensus for that as seen through the
diversity of opinion among believers in the context of salvation over the centuries. It is an insurmountable task to prove from
scriptures that the supposed shades of grey are nothing more than a figment of
imagination on the part of many believers because biblical evidence is
customarily produced in support of it such as has been done in the current
sub-study. The natural conclusion is
that there are indeed shades of grey in the context of salvation in scriptures. If is of necessity that the doctrine of
salvation properly accounts for them.
The following is a summary of
what has been concluded through validation of issue #2:
Repentance causatively
precedes salvation.
Repentance
causatively precedes deliverance from bondage to sin.
Repentance is man s responsibility.
Repentance brings about willingness to obey.
Regeneration, the granting of the gift of faith and deliverance
from bondage to sin by the Holy Spirit are chronologically synchronous, with
regeneration causative-immediately preceding the granting of the gift of faith,
which in turn causative-immediately precedes deliverance.
Belief in the context of scriptures can
refer to mere mental assent, more than mental assent but not necessarily faith,
or faith.
Belief as in
mental assent to
the good news of Jesus Christ that is accompanied by repentance causatively
precedes regeneration,
the granting of the gift of faith and deliverance from bondage to sin by the
Holy Spirit with regeneration, the granting of the gift of faith and
deliverance being chronologically synchronous and regeneration
causative-immediately preceding the granting of the gift of faith, which in
turn causative-immediately precedes deliverance.
Unbelief
leads to the blinding of the mind of an unbeliever by the god of this age and
the non-granting of the gift of faith by God.
Though
he is willing, a repentant person is not able to escape the destruction of sin
on his own; God has to deliver him, which is a sovereign act of God.
God
provisions for the elect the root cause, the preceding and independent part of
the intermediate cause and the immediate cause while man the subsequent and
dependent part of the intermediate cause on the only causal chain of deliverance
from bondage to sin.
The following is a summary of
what has been concluded through validation of issue #3:
Continuing to repent and to be willing to obey instructions in
scriptures post deliverance from bondage
to sin is the responsibility of the person who has been delivered, not God s.
Provisioning repentance and willingness to obey
instructions in scriptures for running the course of salvation is not about man
working for his salvation.
Deliverance from the ultimate destruction of sin at the
end of the age and obedience in deeds throughout life are the peer end effects
of the causal chain of salvation as a lifelong process
The following is a summary of
what has been concluded through validation of issue #4:
God does not
grant repentance only to some but instead the privilege of repentance to all
and on rare occasions special enablement for
repentance.
Anyone
who opposes the truth needs special enablement from God for repentance. If he harbors conflict of interest with the
truth, he will not repent even with God s special enablement. If he harbors no conflict of interest with
the truth, he will.
The following is a summary of
what has been concluded through validation of issue #5:
The bible does not provide a concrete specific
reason why some people have the opportunity to hear the good news of Jesus
Christ and hence the opportunity to repent and to be saved
while others do not.
Man can choose to repent or refuse to
repent after he has heard the good news.
When he repents, God grants him the gift of faith. For those who refuse to repent, God sometimes
provides special enablement for repentance.
God providing special enablement for
repentance happens very rarely.
Providing it is entirely God s sovereign choice. There is no prediction when or under what
circumstance God would do it.
While
it is uncertain for lack of information in scriptures whether God shows
favoritism in providing special enablement for repentance, it is certain based
on biblical evidence that God does not show favoritism in that he grants the
gift of faith to all who repent without exception.
Not all who are
delivered from bondage to sin will receive salvation. If a person refuses to continue to repent and
to be willing to obey instructions in scriptures post deliverance from bondage
to sin, God will stop granting him the gift of faith and he will shipwreck his
faith.
God is the beginning and the end of man s salvation. Man is held accountable for what happens in
between the provisioning of repentance and willingness to obey the good news
of Jesus Christ. The essence of this
plain and simple common-sense-based model of salvation can be captured in the
following prescriptive statement:
Repent and obey; believe and be saved!